Project Need
Need For Project:
The White River riparian corridor has become increasingly dominated by Russian olive (Elaeagnus angustifolia) and tamarisk (Tamarix chinensis). These invasives replace native plant communities by creating dense monocultures, preventing native plants from establishing or re-establishing along the riparian corridor. The impacts from these infestations include the reduction and elimination of native plant communities, directly reducing the plant community diversity, insect diversity, wildlife habitat diversity, aggressive fuels accumulation, and reduction of cottonwood galleries which are important sources of large woody debris for fish habitat in the river. Additionally the infestations armor the stream bank preventing lateral dissipation of stream energy, effectively narrowing and deepening the channel resulting in a loss of instream habitat complexity. This disconnects the stream from the riparian zone reducing the amount of floodplain and backwater habitat available to juvenile fish; backwater zones are important habitats for many of the native endangered and conservation agreement fishes in the White River. Control and removal of both Russian olive and tamarisk infestations are critical to a healthy and functioning riparian system, which directly affects the overall health of the watershed. The goal of this project is to reduce Russian olive and tamarisk densities along the river, restore native plant communities, and improve instream conditions for native fish.
Objectives:
1) Improve water quality of the White River
2) Decrease the stems/acre of Russian olive and tamarisk
3) Restore Cottonwood Galleries
4) Reduce Hazardous fuel loads
5) Restore natural geomorphic process, and improve instream fish habitat
Project Location/Timing Justification (Why Here? Why Now?):
The continued expansion and dominance of Russian olive and tamarisk in plant communities along the White River reduces native plant recruitment, diversity, and density. Invasive plant infestations degrade channel form resulting in loss of instream habitat and complexity for native endangered and conservation agreement fishes. A secondary risk is the continued expansion of these invasive species into other connected tributaries and subsequent increases in fuel accumulations that could result in more intense and extreme fire events. Large and hotter fires would ultimately lead to a loss of cottonwoods and willows and the wildlife habitat they provide, as well as increasing the potential for continued infestation by these non-native species. This cycle can then repeat all but eliminating the native riparian communities.
Relation To Management Plan:
Vernal BLM Fire Management Plan *Chemical treatments would be utilized in conjunction with prescribed fire and mechanical treatments to achieve desired objectives, and to also control invasive species. Vernal RMP ROD Works towards Goals and objectives for Special Status Species in the Vernal RMP (pg. 128) Vegetation Management Decisions; *VEG-4; Manage the vegetation to attain the ecological stage that will benefit wildlife in crucial habitat and livestock grazing. Manage vegetation in remaining areas that results in high vegetation species diversity. *VEG-5; Allow mechanical, fire, biological, cultural or chemical methods for vegetation manipulation, using the type of manipulation appropriate to and consistent with other land use objectives, and incorporating standard operation procedures and BMP's, as applicable, to protect other resources. *VEG-9; Manage the vegetation to attain the ecological stage that will: ensure sustainability, meet authorized use allocations (wildlife,livestock),ensure species diversity. Deer Statewide Management Plan *The plan states mule deer do best in habitats that are in the early stages of plant succession this project returns portions of the White River Corridor to this state. Other threats include catastrophic Fire, and expansion of invasive plant species resulting in loss or degradation of habitat. Habitat objective 2 line e: states use WRI to improve riparian habitats throughout Utah. Strategic Management Plan for Wild Turkey 2000: Suitable general habitat includes 3 key ingredients, trees, forbs, and grass which are not found in invasive species monocultures. Which is what the White River corridor will become without management action. The plan states cottonwood riparian habitats are most important for Rio Grande Subspecies of wild turkeys, this project restores that habitat; *. Yellow-billed Cuckoo, A Technical Conservation Assessment Utah-Conservation Strategy *The plans recommendations for Utah include: maintain/improve natural flow regimes in riverine/riparian systems. By removing highly flammable tamarisk biomass, the project protects the riparian resource and supports Objective #1 for Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity in Utah's Wildlife Action Plan (WAP, 2015): "Fire is excluded from habitats in which potential burns now would be frequent, large, and destructive to soils and native vegetation; the habitats are being actively managed (treated) to reduce components or factors that promote risk of catastrophic fire...". Project actions also support Objective #2 for Invasive Plant Species (WAP, 2015), which reads: "Invasive plant dominance/presence is reduced or eliminated in locations or habitats where such an outcome is realistic (ecologically and economically)." Three Species Range wide Conservation Agreement/Utah Three Species Plan: The three species are currently managed under a range-wide and state conservation agreement to which the BLM and UDWR are signatories. The proposed restoration specifically targets improvement of these species population by improving habitat and implementation of a monitoring plan, helping accomplish the goals of the agreement. Upper Colorado River Endangered Fish Recovery Program:The endangered Colorado pikeminnow, razorback sucker, and humpback chub have all been observed in the White River. The proposed project will benefit these endangered species and contribute toward the goal of recovering population of each species.
Fire / Fuels:
Russian olive alter the structure of plant communities by increasing vertical and horizontal canopy density, increasing fuel continuity, and creating volatile fuel ladders (Zouhar et al. 2008, Katz and Shafroth 2003). Tamarisk and Russian olive can form dense, fire prone thickets that develop into monospecific stands because of vigorous root sprout growth following fire. The potential for more extreme fires will intensify as the density and cover of the tamarisk and Russian olive encroachment increases. By reducing the hazardous fuel load will reduce the possibility for fire events. Increased fire frequency and intensity favor tamarisk and Russian olive re-establishment over less fire adapted native riparian species, such as willow and cottonwood, which are slower to re-sprout post fire (Zouhar 2003).
Water Quality/Quantity:
Tamarisk and Russian olive have a major impact on hydrology and soil chemistry. Large-scale tamarisk removal has the potential to improve water quality by reducing salinity levels of soils in riparian habitats. In addition, tamarisk tends to have higher rates of evapotranspiration than the native upland plants that it tends to displace from floodplain habitats. Removal of tamarisk and Russian olive has been linked to saving water and over time water quality increases (Shafroth et al. 2009).
Compliance:
NEPA was completed by the VFO BLM in December 2014, included in the NEPA are avoidance measures for archeology and cultural resources. A Pesticide Use Proposal will be submitted to the BLM before application of chemicals.
Methods:
The removal of the Russian olive and tamarisk will be conducted by Conservation Corps using a cut-stump method, in some places Frill cut will be used on Russian olive. After cutting tamarisk and Russian olive stems with chain saws, crews will pile the slash and treat stumps with herbicide. Where possible limbs or tree trunks with an average diameter of 4 inches will limbed and cut to 8-10 foot lengths and placed near the river. The limbing of the logs is expected to minimize potential conflict that could occur between rafters and the addition of large woody debris/habitat to the system. Two habitat treatment areas are planned: one will focus on Cottonwood gallery restoration by removing invasive trees under and near mature cottonwoods, thus allowing for cottonwood recruitment and returning mature Cottonwood stands to galleries with multiple age classes of trees present; the other treatment area will focus on monocultures of invasive trees, opening up areas for recolonization by native plants. In monoculture locations the Tamarisk will be cut and piled, while the Russian olive will be frill cut. Frill cut reduces the re-sprout response and maintains habitat structure while removing competition from invasive vegetation. Treatment sites will be prioritized with the assistance of Utah State University's Riparian Condition Assessment Tool. Sites lacking native vegetation post treatment will be evaluated for survival probability of native plantings, if determined to have high potential native planting will be conducted. Contracting to youth crews will be handled and administered by UDWR with on the ground supervision completed by the Vernal BLM. The cutting is planned for the fall of 2018, with planting later in the fall or in the spring of 2019. Project data will be incorporated into a regional geodatabase of restoration activities in the Colorado, connecting outputs of these efforts to a wider network, and thus increasing future funding opportunities.
Monitoring:
To determine the effectiveness of the treatments, long-term monitoring plots will be established at treatment sites along the White River corridor. Percent cover will be measured pre- and post-treatment. When possible Pre and Post aerial imagery will be captured with a drone camera. A Utah Department of Water Quality monitoring station has been reactivated near the highway 45 bridge through co-ordination with UDEQ and BLM (ID 4933970). For water year 2019 the BLM will propose to reactivate the monitoring site on the Glenn Bench road (ID 4933730). Instream habitat usage by endangered and conservation agreement fishes will be monitored by UDWR fish biologist with the use of portable PIT tag detectors.This is possible because over the last decade tens of thousands of native fish have been tagged and released into the Green River System with some tagging efforts focused in the White. These fish make long distance migrations between the Green River and its tributaries including the White River. Monitoring habitat creation and usage will be instrumental in informing project success and future restoration efforts.
Partners:
Water quality monitoring has been established with UDEQ. Project personnel are working with private landowners to treat infestations on private land. The Tamarisk Coalition is building a restoration partnership to indoctrinate restoration methods, monitoring, and management procedures for the purpose of coordinating with other partners and consistency with long-term efforts. Recently, Tamarisk Coalition personnel have conducted talks with the UTE tribe to collaborate and work on tribal lands. Project personnel are working with Utah State University to use their riparian Condition Assessment Tool to plan and prioritize sites for treatment. A proposal to acquire improved satellite imagery to feed the riparian tool is being developed with the BLM National Operations Center. A memorandum of understanding is being developed by Tamarisk Coalition and reviewed by multiple private and public entities to establish a White River Partnership to develop and implement a comprehensive approach toward the conservation of ah healthy riparian ecosystem for the White River in both Colorado and Utah.
Future Management:
The project is part of a multi-year effort that will involve follow-up monitoring, active re-vegetation, and treatments to control infestations of priority non-native, invasive plant species such as tamarisk and Russian olive, as well as potential secondary weeds that degrade native habitat conditions. The long-term goal is to restore riparian and floodplain habitats along the lower White River in a manner that creates diverse riparian communities comprised primarily of native plant species as a means of improving the condition and resiliency of riparian and aquatic habitats. This will require an adaptive management approach, and Tamarisk Coalition is working with BLM and other partners to establish evaluation criteria and procedures for addressing changing factors. TC will hold technical and coordination workshops with upstream partners also conducting restoration activities to ensure collaborative and coordinated approaches among both Utah and Colorado efforts.
Sustainable Uses of Natural Resources:
Tamarisk and Russian olive can decrease the availability of water for livestock (Hill pers. Comm. 2009). By eliminating large stands of tamarisk and Russian olive in this riparian system livestock will be able to utilize this system and the vegetation diversity benefits this project will achieve. Removing invasive woody vegetation will facilitate the reestablishment of perennial grasses, native forbs, and shrubs that have much higher forage value than tamarisk. However, targeted revegetation and broadcast seeding will accelerate the recolonization of native grasses in selected areas where native grasses are sparse in habitat adjacent to treatment sites. Control of tamarisk can make managing livestock easier. Previously dense stands of tamarisk that have either been removed or thinned (depending on site-conditions) increase access for ranchers to monitor and manage cattle on public allotments. As well, grazing and animal distribution will increase since more river bank is accessible for watering livestock and wildlife.