Mill Creek Canyon Bonneville Cutthroat Trout Spawning Channel Design- FY20 Construction-FY21
Project ID: 4947
Status: Cancelled
Fiscal Year: 2020
Submitted By: N/A
Project Manager: Vic Rowberry
PM Agency: Boy Scouts of America
PM Office: Great Salt Lake Council
Lead: Boy Scouts of America
WRI Region: Central
Description:
Improvements to the existing lake at Boy Scout Camp Tracy in Mill Creek Canyon to include a Bonneville Cutthroat Trout (BCT) spawning channel. The project includes dredging of the lake, removal and replacement of an existing creek diversion structure, installation of a pipeline, relocation of the lake overflow, construction of a spawning channel at the inlet to the lake, and all of the water facilities required to support a lake with a natural reproducing BCT fishery.
Location:
The project is located at Camp Tracy in Salt Lake County. Camp Tracy is located in Mill Creek Canyon, two and 1/2 miles east from the mouth of the canyon.
Project Need
Need For Project:
In 1918 Alvin V. Taylor deed 1,100 acres to the Boy Scouts of America to support outdoor activities for young people. For more than 100 years Camp Tracy has created opportunities for youth to experience the outdoors. Located at Camp Tracy in Mill Creek Canyon is an off-channel reservoir named for the memory of Alvin Taylor, Taylor Lake. Water is diverted from Mill Creek and forms the reservoir before re-entering Mill Creek through an outflow structure. (Mill Creek is the stream within Mill Creek Canyon.) Largely due to short-circuiting between reservoir inflow and outflow structures (both located in the same area of the lake). The location of the inflow and outflow result in poor circulation, limited oxygen flow and the shallow lake frequently overgrows with algae and achieves high water temperatures uninhabitable for trout species. These warm temperatures, low oxygen and overgrowth then degrades water quality in Mill Creek downstream as the lakes outflow returns to the main channel. BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY Mill Creek is home to Bonneville Cutthroat Trout (BCT) (Oncorhynchus clarkii utah), a native species that historically inhabited Mill Creek and a prized Utah sportfish featured in Utah's Cutthroat Slam. The Division of Wildlife Resources (DWR) has prioritized the reintroduction and protection of BCT within its historical native habitat, reintroducing the species along with other native fish species in Mill Creek as part of this effort. Improved water quality and increased habitat within the Mill Creek watershed could facilitate the success of these reintroduction efforts, improve the fishery, educate up to 18,000 visitors annually of the importance of native trout conservation, and reduce the costs and resources devoted to continuous fish stocking and potential introduction of non-native fish species back into the Mill Creek Watershed. WATER QUALITY Mill Creek, a tributary to the Jordan River, is an important water resource along the Wasatch Front. Millcreek serves as an ecological resource, a recently restored native fishery, and as a local water supply. The water supplying Taylor Lake comes from Millcreek and after flowing through the lake is diverted back to Millcreek. Actions taken to improve water quality at Taylor Lake will benefit downstream water quality and the health of the system overall.
Objectives:
The primary project objectives are focused on SUSTAINABILITY, including: * Create a spawning channel for BCT with a goal of creating a sustainable population of BCT. This will avoid the potential of non-native fish being brought into the canyon. * Increase the depth, alter the flow regime, and improve the habitat of Taylor Lake * Create an educational setting for the ~18,000 annual visitors to learn about BCT, trout lifecycles, and watershed restoration * Replace and restore an existing Mill Creek diversion * Restore and revegetate portions of Camp Tracy SPAWNING GROUNDS This project will transform Taylor Lake from a warm and overgrown reservoir which degrades the water quality of Mill Creek into a cold water BCT fishery. A meandering spawning channel will replace the existing inlet structure in the reservoir. The channel will be constructed to support the BCT population in the reservoir, allow natural BCT recruitment and serve as an educational viewpoint for visitors and youth groups to learn about the native species' lifecycle. LAKE REHABILITATION By altering the depth and shape of the lake bottom, the lake will resist warming and the negative water quality impacts that result. Increasing the lake depth will also reduce the lake bottom vegetation's access to sunlight and prevent overgrowth. The project will also relocate the lake inflow and outflows to provide better circulation and mixing throughout the lake, increasing oxygen flow, minimizing dead space and the warming of the water column that results. Mechanical aeration and mixing will be included as needed to ensure year-round circulation and oxygenation. These alterations will reduce the water temperature reentering Mill Creek from Taylor Lake and reduce the organic matter contributed to Mill Creek from overgrowth in Taylor Lake. Beyond water quality services to Mill Creek and the downstream watershed, the project will transform Taylor Lake into additional habitat for BCT. Cooler water temperatures, better circulation, reduced vegetation, and higher dissolved oxygen concentrations will allow Taylor Lake to support the species. The addition of a meandering spawning channel upstream of the reservoir will provide habitat for the trout in an otherwise piped inflow from Mill Creek Canyon. The meandering spawning channel will feature an ideal gravel medium and flow rate ideal for trout spawning grounds, allowing Taylor Lake to support a naturally reproducing population of BCT. EDUCATION & OUTREACH Camp Tracy offers a unique opportunity to educate the public about Utah's native cutthroat species and watershed restoration efforts. The camp generally serves 15,000-18,000 people each year from a diverse set of groups. In addition to the many Scouts that visit, the camp hosts programs for at-risk youth separate from the scouting program each year. The University of Utah Hospital's Burn Center has a reoccurring program at Camp Tracy bringing visitors each year. Volunteer groups from Trout Unlimited, the Stonefly Society, Boeing, and Dominion Energy have all recently visited and engaged in improving the camp. The restoration of Taylor Lake and the development of the spawning channel would further facilitate these programs, encourage new partnerships, and provide an excellent educational opportunity for all of the camp's visitors. Optimizing the educational potential of Taylor Lake and the corresponding spawning channel has been a major point of emphasis in the early design of the channel. We intend to provide an easily accessible vantage point of the channel and its outfall into the Lake, complete with signs and displays detailing the role of the channel in trout spawning and the genealogy of BCT. More information regarding the effects of watershed restoration, the geologic history of Lake Bonneville and its contributing area, and the overall Mill Creek Canyon BCT Restoration Project will also be displayed on site. PREVIOUSLY COMPLETED WORK Engineering design of the lake dredging project were completed in fiscal year 2017. The BSA spent $35,000 in surveying, engineering evaluations, and engineering design work. The lake dredging design is complete and ready to be incorporated into the overall project construction phase. COST OPINION The majority of the project is currently in the conceptual design phase and thus a detailed construction cost estimate cannot be fully developed. However, a preliminary cost opinion has been developed for both design and construction. These cost opinions are attached to the application. A total project cost, including all design and construction, is approximately 1.2 million dollars.
Project Location/Timing Justification (Why Here? Why Now?):
Due to its shallow depth and lack of circulation Taylor Lake is currently in a eutrophic state. Sediment deposition continues to occur resulting in the lake depth decreasing, light penetration increasing, water temperature increasing, plant growth increasing, and algal blooms increasing. If unaddressed, negative impacts to water quality in Mill Creek will continue or increase.
Relation To Management Plan:
Camp Tracy provides outdoor experiences for young men and women ages 4 to 18. These youth include Scouting and Learning for Life programs which focuses on character building experiences to "enable all students to achieve their full potential." For many of the youth who attend this camp their experiences in the outdoors are their first experiences outside of an urban setting. Taylor Lake is an essential component of these experiences by providing opportunities for youth to experience human powered boats. In addition to boating, if Taylor Lake has a fishery, youth will be allowed to experience fishing at a location not far from home, but in a completely different setting. Addition of a spawning channel will provide a tremendous learning opportunity for tens of thousands of youth who come through Camp Tracy each year to connect with the life cycle of another living being and understand the positive or negative impacts humans can have on our surrounding environment. The restoration of Taylor Lake and the associated spawning channel is one of the last tasks to be completed as part of the Mill Creek Watershed Restoration Project. Mill Creek provides a diverse range of important services and has thus been the focus of a multitude of restoration tasks in recent years. This project makes further progress to the goals of the Mill Creek Watershed Restoration Project and the efforts to reestablish BCT in the watershed. This project is consistent with The Bonneville Cutthroat Trout State-wide and Range-wide Conservation Agreement Strategy, Utah Division of Wildlife Resources, Publication Number 00-19, Salt Lake City, UT; 2015 Salt Lake County Integrated Watershed Plan (protected for cold-water aquatic species p22) and the Wasatch-Cache Forest Plan.
Fire / Fuels:
Camp Tracy and Mill Creek Canyon feature many communities and high-value structures that could be threatened by fire. While reduction of fire risk is not a goal of this project, steps will be taken to reduce the threat of fire as an added benefit of the project. Re-seeding and re-planting efforts near the diversion pipeline, the lake outflow pipeline, and the spawning channel will include the use of fire-wise species. Thick underbrush between the Mill Creek riparian corridor and a major Camp Tracy building will be thinned for the construction of the spawning channel, creating a break in fuels between critical infrastructure and dense forests.
Water Quality/Quantity:
WATER QUALITY The project will improve downstream water quality in Millcreek. By altering the depth and shape of the lake bottom, the lake will resist warming and the negative water quality impacts that occur as a result. Increasing the lake depth will also reduce the lake bottom vegetation's access to sunlight and prevent overgrowth. The project will also relocate the lake inflow and outflows, reducing retention time and providing better circulation and mixing throughout the lake. The shallow dead spaces prone to warming and algae growth will be transformed, improving the water quality in the lake. Mechanical aeration and mixing will be included as needed to ensure year-round circulation and oxygenation. These alterations will reduce the water temperature reentering Mill Creek from Taylor Lake and reduce the amount of organic matter contributed to Mill Creek from overgrowth in Taylor Lake. WATER RIGHTS By increasing the flow-through component of Taylor Lake the evaporation off the lake may decrease and the resulting flow back to Millcreek may slightly increase. Camp Tracy currently holds a 2 cfs non-consumptive water right, from which they currently divert from Mill Creek to Taylor Lake. This project will maintain use of this non-consumptive water right. This project will include the addition of an aboveground flow meter, allowing for greater monitoring and control of water right compliance. The existing diversion structure will be removed and the stream bank rehabilitated. A new diversion structure featuring a self-cleaning coanda screen will minimize stream disturbance, prevent collection of debris, and maintain Mill Creek fish passage. Improvements to the diversion will reduce sedimentation in the lake, prolonging the useful life of Taylor Lake as a BCT fishery.
Compliance:
Not applicable. The camp has been in existence for 100 years and the lake has been in existence for many decades, perhaps 50 years. Construction work will affect areas which wre previously disturbed by manmade activities. There are not any outstanding compliance NEPA or archeology requirements to be addressed.
Methods:
DESIGN PHASE: Engineering design will be conducted by Horrocks Engineers and River Restoration. BSA will provide oversight and ensure project progress and implementation. The USFS, UDWR, and NFF have all been involved in the preliminary design process and their review will be solicited at key design stages to ensure their interests are incorporated. CONSTRUCTION PHASE Upon completion of the design, BSA will bid the project and award the work to an applicable contractor. Horrocks Engineers and River Restoration will provide construction management and oversight to ensure project success. Dredging, excavation, and construction will likely include the use of excavators, dump trucks, and other large equipment. The gravel and cobble needed for the construction of the spawning channel will be sourced from excess material at an existing USFS restoration effort within Mill Creek canyon. The USFS has identified the resource and granted permission to use the material for this project. Greater detail regarding construction methods will emerge as the design progresses.
Monitoring:
There are not any monitoring requirements for the project. However, the project is to be voluntarily completed by the BSA. The United State Forest Service and the Utah Division of Wildlife Resources have consulted on the project and are in favor of the project and will periodically monitor spawning activity of the BCT population in Taylor Lake. The BSA will lead all monitoring of the project and will report progress to the WRI project page. BSA staff at Camp Tracy will provide constant oversight of project progress. BSA and its engineering consultant, Horrocks Engineers, will oversee scheduling of design, construction, and other project assignments.
Partners:
The BSA has spent $36,000 on engineering services for the Taylor Lake dredging and spawning channel design. An additional $15,000 was spent to remove a trading post and the associated structures on the west side of the lake as part of Taylor Lake's restoration. The BSA will contribute more funding towards the design and construction of the spawning channel, the lake dredging, and the relocation of inlets, outlets, and diversion structures. The National Forest Foundation (NFF) has been included in planning of the project and will solicit donations from a wide variety of partners to help complete parts of the project. NFF has affirmed there intent to contribute funds as the project progresses. The restoration of Taylor Lake and spawning channel development is a part of the USFS's larger Mill Creek Watershed Restoration Effort. The USFS has spent approximately $2,000,000 on the Mill Creek watershed restoration efforts thus far. USFS is finalizing their work in Porter Fork, following which fund raising efforts will commence on the final task, being the Taylor Lake restoration and BCT spawning channel. BSA, UDWR, USFS, USFWS, Pacific Corp, Trout Unlimited and many others have all been a part of the Mill Creek Watershed Restoration Project and the BCT Reintroduction in Mill Creek Canyon over the past several years and continue to support this aspect of the overall project. All related agencies, organizations, and landowners related to this project have been contacted and involved in the planning and preliminary design phase. In particular, USFS, UDWR, NFF, and BSA have all had an integral role in the planning of this project, with the interests of each incorporated into the design. USFS have approached a few large corporations about becoming involved in financially supporting this project. This includes Boeing and Dominion Energy. These companies are likely to show support during the construction phase of the project.
Future Management:
As a result of this project the BSA will have the capacity to increase the flow rate which flows through Taylor Lake. The result of this increased flows will be to maintain a high water quality level which will support the aquatic health of the lake. With the completion of the project the BSA will have the ability to control the flow rate diverted into (and out of) the lake and may consider actively regulating (decreasing) the flow rate to mimic natural conditions, as long as lower flow rates do not result in decreases in water quality. The BSA will provide reports of outcomes on reductions in algal growth, decreases in average discharge water temperature, BCT spawning habits, indications on BCT spawning success, numbers of visitors to the project site, and any other applicable outcomes.
Sustainable Uses of Natural Resources:
Improvements to Taylor Lake, and the installation of spawning channel will provide an educational resource for educating camp visitors about lake ecology and fish habitat preservation. It will also provide a recreational opportunity for Scouts and other visitors.
Budget WRI/DWR Other Budget Total In-Kind Grand Total
$100,000.00 $85,000.00 $185,000.00 $20,000.00 $205,000.00
Item Description WRI Other In-Kind Year
Contractual Services Design and permitting $100,000.00 $50,000.00 $20,000.00 2020
Contractual Services Design in FY 2019 $0.00 $35,000.00 $0.00 2019
Funding WRI/DWR Other Funding Total In-Kind Grand Total
$100,000.00 $85,000.00 $185,000.00 $20,000.00 $205,000.00
Source Phase Description Amount Other In-Kind Year
Utah's Watershed Restoration Initiative (UWRI) Funding request $50,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Other Direct cash from National Forest Foundation and Boy Scouts of America in-kind staff time $0.00 $50,000.00 $20,000.00 2020
Other Design funding spent in FY 2019 by BSA $0.00 $35,000.00 $0.00 2019
Habitat Council Account Funding request $50,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Species
Species "N" Rank HIG/F Rank
Bonneville Cutthroat Trout N4 R1
Threat Impact
Channelization / Bank Alteration (direct, intentional) High
Bonneville Cutthroat Trout N4 R1
Threat Impact
Fishing and Harvesting Aquatic Resources High
Waterfowl
Threat Impact
No Threat NA
American Coot R5
Threat Impact
Not Listed NA
Mallard R1
Threat Impact
Droughts High
Habitats
Habitat
Aquatic-Forested
Threat Impact
Channelization / Bank Alteration (direct, intentional) High
Aquatic-Forested
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native Medium
Aquatic-Forested
Threat Impact
Presence of Diversions Very High
Open Water
Threat Impact
Increasing Stream Temperatures Unknown
Open Water
Threat Impact
Temperature Extremes Unknown
Riverine
Threat Impact
Dam / Reservoir Operation Medium
Riverine
Threat Impact
Temperature Extremes Unknown
Project Comments
Comment 02/06/2019 Type: 1 Commenter: Paul Cowley
This project is part of the Mill Creek Watershed Restoration Effort. As funding needs are finalized and the culverts are installed this year in Porter Fork, fund raising efforts will commence for this final task. We have had Boeing, Dominion Energy, and a variety of other partners on site as we've reviewed the project with them.
Comment 02/12/2019 Type: 1 Commenter: N/A
Thanks
Comment 02/12/2019 Type: 1 Commenter: Jimi Gragg
I'm curious why #4947 is not tagged as a Central Region proposal? All the other SLO proposals are for things like statewide training, or staff. This is a normal dirt-turning project (a good one, I'll add). Just a question, not a jab. Thanks for the work.
Comment 02/12/2019 Type: 1 Commenter: N/A
This was a mistake and we have requested that the project be changed to the Central Region in order to get on the agenda for project presentations. Thanks
Comment 02/12/2019 Type: 1 Commenter: Janice Gardner
Will this project require a Section 404 wetlands permit or Stream Alteration Permit?
Comment 02/12/2019 Type: 1 Commenter: N/A
Yes, this project will require a stream alteration permit for the diversion replacement in Mill Creek. This task will be completed before implementation proposed for the next fiscal year. Thank you.
Comment 02/06/2019 Type: 3 Commenter: Paul Cowley
The financial figures for some of the tasks are in draft and still being developed.
Comment 02/12/2019 Type: 3 Commenter: N/A
Thank you
Completion
Start Date:
End Date:
FY Implemented:
Final Methods:
Project Narrative:
Future Management:
Map Features
ID Feature Category Action Treatement/Type
751 Pipeline Construction Below surface
753 Pipeline Construction Below surface
790 Pipeline Modification Below surface
1830 Water development point feature Removal Water Control Structure
1831 Water development point feature Construction Water Control Structure
7724 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Lake/Wetland/Pond Improvements Debris removal
7724 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Lake/Wetland/Pond Improvements Dredging
7724 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Lake/Wetland/Pond Improvements Outlet/spillway modification or repair
7724 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Lake/Wetland/Pond Improvements Slope modification
7724 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Vegetation Improvements Reduction of shallow water area(s)
7725 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Stream Corridor/Channel Improvements Excavation
7725 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Stream Corridor/Channel Improvements Gravel placement
7725 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Stream Corridor/Channel Improvements Instream flow enhancement
7725 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Stream Corridor/Channel Improvements Instream random boulder placement
Project Map
Project Map