Project ID: 4961
Status: Completed
Fiscal Year: 2020
Submitted By:
1352
|
Project Manager: Johnny Neil
PM Agency: Utah Division of Wildlife Resources
PM Office: Southern Region
Lead: Utah Division of Wildlife Resources
WRI Region: Southern
|
Description:
Bitterbrush has been declining in locations throughout Southern Utah. The availability of bitterbrush seed will assist in reversing this trend, as Dedicated Hunters will be planting the seed in critical mule deer wintering areas.
|
|
Location:
Various areas in Southern Region (See map). The Iron County and Millard County locations are too small to see without zooming in; here is a description to easily find those areas: In Millard County, zoom in just north of Holden on the east side of I-15. The Iron County sites are near Summit and Enoch on the east side of I-15, and the two sites just south of Highway 20 on the west side of I-15.
|
Budget | WRI/DWR | Other | Budget Total | In-Kind | Grand Total |
$7,250.00 | $0.00 | $7,250.00 | $40,373.00 | $47,623.00 |
Item | Description | WRI | Other | In-Kind | Year |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Seed (GBRC) | Bitterbrush at 250 pounds | $7,250.00 | $0.00 | $0.00 | 2020 |
Other | Dedicated Hunter Labor | $0.00 | $0.00 | $40,373.00 | 2020 |
Funding | WRI/DWR | Other | Funding Total | In-Kind | Grand Total |
$7,250.00 | $0.00 | $7,250.00 | $40,373.00 | $47,623.00 |
Source | Phase | Description | Amount | Other | In-Kind | Year |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mule Deer Foundation (MDF) | S023 | $3,625.00 | $0.00 | $0.00 | 2020 | |
Utah Division of Wildlife Resources (UDWR) | Dedicated Hunter Labor | $0.00 | $0.00 | $40,373.00 | 2020 | |
Sportsman for Fish & Wildlife (SFW) | S027 | $3,625.00 | $0.00 | $0.00 | 2020 |
Species | "N" Rank | HIG/F Rank | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mule Deer | R1 | |||||
|
||||||
Mule Deer | R1 | |||||
|
||||||
Mule Deer | R1 | |||||
|
Habitat | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Gambel Oak | ||||
|
||||
Gambel Oak | ||||
|
||||
Lowland Sagebrush | ||||
|
||||
Lowland Sagebrush | ||||
|
||||
Mountain Sagebrush | ||||
|
||||
Mountain Sagebrush | ||||
|
||||
Mountain Shrub | ||||
|
||||
Mountain Shrub | ||||
|
Comment | 02/05/2019 | Type: 1 | Commenter: Michael Golden |
Johnny, Looks like a great low cost high reward project for mule deer. A few comments/questions. First off I think you should get bonus points for using the phrase " evil trees of darkness." I also want to give you bonus points for not trying to tell me how planting bitterbrush will benefit some snake or raptor species with an N value. Any chance you could load some supplemental maps or provide some steering directions on where the Iron and Millard County sites are. I found the 1300 acres in Kane but am struggling with the smaller acreages. So perhaps you could fill the stupid fish guy in on why these specific sites were chosen over other sites where Phase III PJ has been removed. What are current conditions on the sites like and from a deer or veg perspective why do we need to complete this project right now...is there a threshold that will be crossed making the project more difficult in the next 5 years? Nice use of the herd plans in your relationship to plans section. I am thinking you could sell the hunting value of at least the Kane County sites a bit better in your other sustainable uses section. Any depredation issues the project might help alleviate? How does this tie into all the other projects ongoing in the different watersheds to contribute to watershed health? Any actual deer monitoring? Photo points? Any discussion of work across adjacent land ownership? How will you ensure the success of these seedings? Deferment from grazing? Reseeding if a certain success rate is not met? Can you elaborate on how the project addresses the Invasive species -- Nonnative threat...while PJ are evil trees of darkness, they are most certainly native, just like the coyotes we have a bounty on. | |||
Comment | 02/06/2019 | Type: 1 | Commenter: Curtis Roundy |
Johnny is out for a bit so to help out I will help you to find the sites, and answer some of the questions that you asked. The Iron County sites are located in two different general areas. The first area is near the Parowan front in areas that have been lop and scattered and/or are planned to be bullhogged. The second location is close to Jackrabbit Spring in the hills north of the Parowan Gap. The Millard County Site is located Northeast of the town of Holden on the East Side of I15. All of the sites were chosen through a collaboration of the District Biologists from UDWR and the Habitat Staff from UDWR. The sites were chosen in areas where projects to remove the "evil trees of darkness" have previously been implemented or are planned to be implemented prior to the planting. This would allow the area to recover a historic veg species that was there and in some instances there are old decadent remnants remaining. If we don't plant these areas in the next five years we expect that they will fill in with grasses and other species some possibly non-desirable, and this would make establishment of bitterbrush much more difficult. This project in all cases is tying into previous WRI projects as a follow up supplemental seeding to try to establish bitterbrush in treatment areas such as a recent bullhog project. Overall as you plant and grow desirable vegetation in these project areas and create the best vegetative community possible you are improving the watershed health as well as creating healthy rangelands that are productive and produce feed and forage for livestock and wildlife. Some of these sites have deer monitoring routes that run through the project area and we count deer in these areas during the winter to help us determine buck to doe ratios and help make management decisions that allow us to follow our management plans. As for how the project addresses the Invasive Species--Nonnative threat, we believe that as we complete these projects (bullhog, chaining etc.) we have a window in which we can establish the desirable species that we would like to see on the landscape (usually 1-3 years). If we fail at establishing the species that we would like to see on the landscape most often what we see instead is takeover by invasive nonnative species, so any attempt to thwart this takeover and invasion of the project areas by seeding desirable species we believe is directly addressing the invasive species -- Nonnnative threat. | |||
Comment | 02/06/2019 | Type: 1 | Commenter: Heather Talley |
Hey Mike - thanks for the comments! I coordinated with some of the wildlife and habitat biologists to answer the remaining questions in Johnny's absence. Thank you, Curtis, for the awesome responses to these comments! I've just itemized each question with a bullet point beneath it to depict the response for each individual question: Directions to Millard and Iron County sites now listed in the "Short Description of Project" comment box. a. Parowan Front have been lop-and-scattered and/or plan to be bullhogged. 2) Why are these specific sites chosen over other sites where Phase III PJ have been removed? 2a) What are current conditions on the sites like, and from a deer or veg perspective, why do we need to complete this project right now....is there a threshold that will be crossed, making the project more difficult in the next 5 years? a. The sites were chosen in areas where projects to remove the "evil trees of darkness" have previously been implemented or are planned to be implemented prior to the planting. This would allow the area to recover a historic veg species that was there, and in some instances, there are old decadent remnants remaining. If we don't plant these areas in the next five years, we expect that they will fill in with grasses and other species some possibly non-desirable, and this would make establishment of bitterbrush much more difficult. 3) Need to sell hunting value more in the sustainable uses section a. Kane County -- good fawning range, and may keep a few deer out of private lands and make them available for the public. Millard and Iron County sites are good for winter range; Iron County sites will provide habitat for deer, and Millard County sites will contribute to elk and deer habitat. 4) Any depredation issues the project might help alleviate? a. Each of these areas may help to keep some big game from moving into the surrounding cultivated areas. 5) How does this tie into all other projects ongoing in the different watersheds to contribute to watershed health? a. This project in all cases is tying into previous WRI projects as a follow up supplemental seeding to try to establish bitterbrush in treatment areas such as a recent bullhog project. Overall as you plant and grow desirable vegetation in these project areas and create the best vegetative community possible you are improving the watershed health as well as creating healthy rangelands that are productive and produce feed and forage for livestock and wildlife. 6) Any actual deer monitoring? a. Some of these sites have deer monitoring routes that run through the project area and we count deer in these areas during the winter to help us determine buck to doe ratios and help make management decisions that allow us to follow our management plans. 7) Photo points? a. Sites will be monitored by wildlife and habitat sections to assess growth of bitterbrush and usage of adult plants. Previous bitterbrush plantings have had 100 foot transects established on sites with planting occurring every foot in order to establish a percent germination and eventually establishment. One or two of these sites will also be established in these project areas. Photos will be taken from point of origin on transect. 8) Any discussion of work across adjacent landownership? a. Project sites are identified on DWR, BLM and other state lands. 9) How will you ensure the success of these seedings? Deferment from grazing? Reseeding if a certain success rate is not met? a. It is anticipated that this will become an annual proposal to help aid habitat projects with sites suitable for bitterbrush re-establishment. Future site selection will be informed as we look at success rates on these sites and identify the best suitable sites for future plantings. 10) Can you elaborate on how the project addresses the invasive species -- nonnative threat a. As for how the project addresses the Invasive Species--Nonnative threat, we believe that as we complete these projects (bullhog, chaining etc.) we have a window in which we can establish the desirable species that we would like to see on the landscape (usually 1-3 years). If we fail at establishing the species that we would like to see on the landscape, most often what results is a takeover by invasive nonnative species, so any attempt to thwart this takeover and invasion of the project areas by seeding desirable species we believe is directly addressing the invasive species -- nonnnative threat. | |||
Comment | 02/13/2019 | Type: 1 | Commenter: Clint Wirick |
While most of us have a pretty good idea on how the seed will be planted it'd be good to bolster up the methods section for those who might not know. | |||
Comment | 02/13/2019 | Type: 1 | Commenter: Johnny Neil |
I have added that the seed will be planted via drill seeding. Thanks for the tip. | |||
Comment | 02/13/2019 | Type: 1 | Commenter: Johnny Neil |
A document will be added to explain how the seed will be planted | |||
Comment | 02/13/2019 | Type: 1 | Commenter: Gary Bezzant |
While dedicated hunters have come to call the Bitterbrush seed planter a drill seeder, it is not a traditional seed drill that is pulled behind a tractor but is actually a hand tool (Gopher Mole Bait Applicator) modified specifically for the planting of bitterbrush seed. I have attached a history of the tool to the documents tab. | |||
Comment | 08/26/2020 | Type: 2 | Commenter: Alison Whittaker |
This is just a reminder that completion reports are due August 31st. I have entered the expenses in the Through WRI/DWR column on the finance page. Please do not make any changes to numbers in the Through WRI/DWR column. Any "Through Other" or "In-kind" expenses will need to be entered by the PM or contributors. Be sure to click on the finalize button on the completion report when you have your completion report ready to be reviewed by WRI Admin. Don't forget to upload any pictures of the project you have of before, during and after completion. Thanks. | |||
Comment | 10/22/2021 | Type: 2 | Commenter: Alison Whittaker |
I am assuming this project is completed? Please submit a completion report, update map features and enter missing expenses. Thanks! |
ID | Feature Category | Action | Treatement/Type |
---|---|---|---|
7742 | Terrestrial Treatment Area | Seeding (secondary/shrub) | Hand seeding |
7758 | Terrestrial Treatment Area | Seeding (secondary/shrub) | Hand seeding |
7759 | Terrestrial Treatment Area | Seeding (secondary/shrub) | Hand seeding |
7760 | Terrestrial Treatment Area | Seeding (secondary/shrub) | Hand seeding |
7803 | Terrestrial Treatment Area | Seeding (secondary/shrub) | Hand seeding |