2019 Neck Fire ESR
Project ID: 5152
Status: Completed
Fiscal Year: 2020
Submitted By: 1156
Project Manager: Martin Esplin
PM Agency: Bureau of Land Management
PM Office: Cedar City
Lead: Bureau of Land Management
WRI Region: Southern
Description:
The 2019 Neck Fire encompassed 18,769 acres (16,305 acres - BLM), (1,954 acres - SITLA) and (510 acres - private). This area is important habitat for Greater Sage Grouse and Utah Prairie Dog, as well as crucial mule deer winter range and livestock grazing land. This project will reestablish vegetation by chaining and reseeding restore wildlife habitat and range.
Location:
The fire occurred in northern Iron County. The fire started in an area commonly known as the Neck of the Desert and spread northeast through the Narrows into Horse Valley. The east end of the fire area is approximately 7 miles south of Minersville, Utah and 4 miles west of SR130. It extends to the southwest approximately 10 miles. The fire burned in portions of six grazing allotments (Adams Well, Desert, Lowe Jones, Minersville 3, Minersville 5 and Nada).
Project Need
Need For Project:
The wildfire burned important habitat for Utah prairie dog (UPD) (9,499 acres), Greater Sage-grouse (brood rearing (9,331 acres), (summer (9,331 acres) and (winter (16,422 acres), mule deer (crucial winter (11,420 acres), pronghorn (year-round (8,586 acres) and livestock grazing lands. The Emergency Stabilization and Rehabilitation (ES&R) project will focus on re-establishing wildlife habitats; specifically, for Utah prairie dog and Sage Grouse throughout the wildfire area. The two primary species that were impacted by the fire were the Utah Prairie Dog and the sage grouse. A portion of the project area is located in the Adams Well Utah Prairie Dog Management Unit. This area has been identified as critical for the recovery of the Utah Prairie Dog. ES&R efforts are expected to help provide additional Utah prairie dog habitat to ensure that the Utah Prairie Dog Management Unit Plan Path to Recovery is attainable in the short-term and long-term. The wildfire also occurred within a portion of the Bald Hills Sage Grouse Priority Habitat Management Area (PHMA). Past sage grouse telemetry data indicates that a considerable portion of the wildfire perimeter has been utilized by sage grouse. The ES&R project will be designed to benefit all wildlife species that are present in the area. Multiple treatments have been identified in the wildfire perimeter as follows: 1. Cultural Clearances - 10,853 acres 2. General Wildlife (Grass/Forb) (Aerial Seeding/Chaining) - 13,208 acres + 1,673 SITLA 3. Sage Grouse and General Wildlife (Aerial Seeding Only) - 2,355 acres + 71 SITLA 4. Sage Grouse (Shrub) (Aerial Seeding/Chaining) - 10,129 acres + 1,673 SITLA 5. Fuel Breaks/Green Strips (Grass/Forb (Aerial Seeding/Chaining) - 729 acres + 61 SITLA 6. Chaining - 10,853 acres 7. Sagebrush Seedling Planting - 2,000 acres 8. Bitterbrush Seedling Planting - 250 acres 9. Plateau Treatments - 2,149 acres + 362 SITLA 10. Sage Grouse Telemetry - 10 - 15 solar PTT transmitters 11. Wildlife Guzzler (Replacement/Upgrade) - 1 guzzler
Objectives:
The overall objective of this project is to rehabilitate the burned area to provide habitat for wildlife (i.e. Greater Sage Grouse, Utah Prairie Dog, mule deer, pronghorn, etc...) and livestock grazing. This will be accomplished by seeding a diverse mix of perennial grasses, forbs and shrubs. The long-term goal of the project is to improve the areas resistance and resilience to future wildfires and to the spread of invasive species including cheatgrass.
Project Location/Timing Justification (Why Here? Why Now?):
Cheatgrass has high probability of returning and re-establishing before other plant species due to the nature of this annual grass. As this happens, other plant species struggle to re-establish, which results in the landscape being dominated by cheatgrass. If the area is not rehabilitated through ES&R efforts it is expected that a pattern of more fires similar to the Neck Fire will continue to occur within the area. The proposed treatment is expected to increase the likelihood of desirable plant species (perennial grasses, forbs and shrubs) to re-establish. A more diverse and fire resistant vegetative community would provide desirable wildlife habitat. Annual precipitation fluctuations may affect the germination and establishment of seeds that are planted; however, the project is located at an elevation of 5,000 - 6,000 feet, which is expected to help counteract the impacts of drought. Typically, rangelands at this elevation receive adequate precipitation to promote vegetative growth and viability in the short-term and long-term.
Relation To Management Plan:
The project is consistent with the following BLM land use plans and associated decisions: * Cedar Beaver Garfield Antimony Resource Management Plan Resource Management Plan (1986). * Utah Greater Sage-Grouse Approved Approved Resource Management Plans as Amended (ARMPAs 2015 and 2019) * Southwest Utah Support Area Fire Management Plan (May, 2006) * The project is in conformance with the Normal Year Fire Stabilization and Rehabilitation Plan Environmental Assessment (EA UT-0040-03-28). The project is in conformance with the applicable land use plans because it is provided for in the following land use plan decisions: Record of Decision and Approved Utah Greater Sage-Grouse Resource Management Plan Amendments (2015 and 2019) Goal SSS-1: Maintain and/or increase GRSG abundance and distribution by conserving, enhancing, or restoring the sagebrush ecosystem upon which populations depend in collaboration with other conservation partners Special Status Species (SSS): Objectives SSS-1, SSS-2, SSS-3, SSS-4, and SSS-5; Management Actions (MA) MA-SSS-1, MA-SSS-3, and MA-SSS-4, MA-SSS-7. Vegetation (VEG): Objective VEG-1; MA-VEG-1, MA-VEG-2, MA-VEG-3, MA-VEG-4, MA-VEG-5, MA-VEG-6, MA-VEG-10, MA-VEG-11, MA-VEG-12, MA-VEG-14. Fire and Fuels Management (FIRE): MA-FIRE-2, and MA-FIRE-3. Other Plans/Strategies Utah Conservation Plan for Greater Sage-Grouse (2019) State of Utah Executive Order 2015/002- Implementing the Utah Conservation Plan for Greater Sage-Grouse (2015) Utah State Wildlife Action Plan (2015) State of Utah Resource Management Plan (2018) National Fire Plan (2000) Utah Pronghorn Statewide Management Plan (2009) Southwest Desert Deer Herd Unit Management Plan (2015) Coordinated Implementation Plan for Bird Conservation in Utah (2005) Local Sage-Grouse Working Group Plans Southwest Desert Greater Sage-Grouse Local Conservation Plan (2009)
Fire / Fuels:
The Neck fire encompassed 18,769 acres. In addition, numerous large fires (Baboon, Badger, Black Mountain, Maple Springs, Roundabout, Rush Lake and Wrangler) have burned within the immediate vicinity of the project area. The Neck Fire is located in the Mineral Black Mountain Fire Management Unit (FMU) (646,151 acres). Approximately 241,620 acres have burned over the past 20 years within this FMU. This amounts to over 37% of the FMU being impacted by high intensity wildfire. Approximately 40,000 acres have burned more than once (cheatgrass burn/re-burn cycle). Most alarming is the fact that for the 22 years in which fire records are available (1993-2014) the number of fires has decreased over the past 10 years; however, the acreages burned has increased more than 200%. If the Neck ES&R project does not occur it is expected that cheatgrass will invade and dominate this area. Future fires will continue to be more difficult to control and have devastating effects by burning at a higher intensity, which could lead to fires getting larger and burning unburned habitat. Treatments identified within this proposal, including seeding with more fire resistant vegetation and creation of fuel breaks/green strips are expected to reduce the overall threat of future wildfires, which could impact unburned areas in the watershed.
Water Quality/Quantity:
The Project Area is located at 5,000 - 6,000 feet above sea level; therefore, it is expected that the opportunity to restore herbaceous species to the composition and frequency appropriate to the area is high. The project is expected to stabilize and improve the herbaceous understory that was burned in the fire, which will reduce water runoff and decrease soil erosion while increasing infiltration. Improvements to the Standards and Guidelines for Healthy Rangelands (Standard 1 and Standard 3) are expected through project implementation. It is expected that Standard 1 (Soils) -- will improve by allowing soils to exhibit permeability and infiltration rates that will sustain/improve site productivity throughout the area. This will be accomplished by making improvements to the Biotic Integrity of the community by restoring areas to a diverse component of perennial grasses, forbs and shrubs that were present prior to the wildfire. Indicators will include sufficient cover and litter to protect the soil surface from excessive water and wind erosion, limiting surface flow and limiting soil moisture loss through evaporation, which will promote proper infiltration.
Compliance:
The treatment will be rested from livestock grazing for a minimum of two years (2 growing seasons) following project implementation to ensure adequate rest and seedling establishment. A cultural contract will be issued and cultural clearances will be completed prior to the project implementation. Project Inspectors will ensure that all contract specifications are adhered to for aerial seeding, chaining, etc... Extensive monitoring data (upland and wildlife) has been collected throughout the area, which will provide baseline data to determine the success of the treatments.
Methods:
The following are the methods for each treatment type: 1. Cultural Clearances Cultural Clearances will be completed prior to project implementation. 2. Sage Grouse and General Wildlife (Aerial Seeding/Chaining) A diverse seed mix (perennial grass, forb and shrub) will be identified to promote successful rehabilitation to improve wildlife habitat. Chaining will be utilized to cover the seed. 3. Sage Grouse and General Wildlife (Aerial Seeding Only) A diverse seed mix (perennial grass, forb and shrub) will be identified to promote successful rehabilitation to improve wildlife habitat. Steep and rocky areas will only be aerially seeded. 4. Utah Prairie Dog (Aerial Seeding/Chaining) A diverse seed mix (perennial grass and forb) will be identified to promote successful rehabilitation to improve wildlife habitat. Chaining will be utilized to cover the seed. 5. Fuel Breaks/Green Strips (Seed Mix/Chaining) An aggressive seed mix (perennial grass and forb) will be identified along major roads and travel corridors. Fuel Breaks/Green Strips will provide a barrier to control spread of future wildfires, contain the spread of a wildfire from a source and provide for fire fighter protection. Chaining will be utilized to cover the seed. 6. Sagebrush Seedling Planting Sagebrush seedling planting will occur in areas that provide habitat connectivity for sage grouse. Information from past telemetry studies will be utilized to identify these areas. 7. Bitterbrush Seedling Planting Bitterbrush seedling planting will occur in areas that have been identified as important for mule deer. 8. Plateau Treatments Plateau treatments will be utilized in areas where there are cheatgrass concerns. 9. Sage Grouse Telemetry The sage grouse telemetry will be utilized to determine if habitat loss and/or fragmentation is a constraint, determine dispersal and connectivity of habitat, determine if there are changes to previously documented sage grouse corridors and allow for analysis of sage grouse use of treatments at various stages of succession (i.e. Neck Wildfire and new treatments vs. 3-5 year old treatments). (Refer to Neck Fire Sage Grouse Telemetry Proposal). 10. Wildlife Guzzler (Replacement/Upgrade) There are three wildlife guzzlers within the wildfire perimeter. The guzzlers provide important water sources for pronghorn and mule deer.
Monitoring:
Monitoring data would be collected at 10 key management areas (8 existing and 2 new). Monitoring may include some support from UDWR or other cooperators. Standard surveys will include: Nested Frequency (Trend), Line Intercept (Shrub Cover and Age Class), Standards and Guidelines for Rangeland Health Assessment, Photo Points, Noxious weed inventory/monitoring. In addition, 2-6 AIM plots would be established within the wildfire perimeter. Vegetation and wildlife monitoring data will be collected throughout the project area to determine the success of the ES&R efforts. This monitoring data will be compiled into an overall monitoring report that will help determine the level of success for the project in the short-term and long-term. Sage Grouse telemetry data has been collected in the area in the past. If funding is received a follow-up sage grouse project would occur within the area. The goals of the project would be as follows: * Determine if habitat loss and/or fragmentation is a constraint within the Bald Hills PHMA * Determine dispersal and connectivity of habitat within the Bald Hills PHMA * Determine if there are changes to previously documented sage grouse corridors * Allow for analysis of sage grouse use of treatments at various stages of succession (i.e. Neck Wildfire and new treatments vs. 3-5 year old treatments). It is expected that all treatments identified would at the minimum serve as opportunity areas even if sage grouse do not move into them immediately following treatment.
Partners:
The BLM Cedar City Field Office will be working with Utah Watershed Restoration Initiative to complete this project. SITLA will be involved because state lands (1,954 acres) were burned in the fire. Of the 1,954 acres of trust lands 1,673 will be chained, 1,744 will be seeded, 362 will be treated with plateau, and 61 acres will be put into green strips. Non-use agreements will be identified with livestock permittees to ensure adequate rest following project implementation.
Future Management:
A mandatory 2 year (growing season) minimum rest period will be initiated for the portions of the allotments that were burned. Deferrment of livestock grazing for a minimum of two years (two growing seasons) will be used to exclude livestock from the burned area to provide seeded species the opportunity to establish.
Sustainable Uses of Natural Resources:
The fire burned in portions of six grazing allotments (Adams Well, Desert, Lowe Jones, Minersville 3, Minersville 5 and Nada). Ten livestock grazing permittees have been impacted by the wildfire. The areas or pastures burned will need to be rested from grazing for a minimum of two years (growing seasons). In the long term, this project will likely have an overall positive impact on domestic livestock grazing because of added forage value following seeding.
Budget WRI/DWR Other Budget Total In-Kind Grand Total
$3,526,186.00 $512,500.00 $4,038,686.00 $6,250.00 $4,044,936.00
Item Description WRI Other In-Kind Year
Personal Services (permanent employee) ES&R plan preparation, cadastral surveys, fence replacement, noxious weed inventories and noxious weed spraying, for the burned area by BLM personnel. $0.00 $361,500.00 $0.00 2020
Contractual Services AIM monitoring contract for 3 years on BLM administered lands. $0.00 $30,000.00 $0.00 2020
Archaeological Clearance Cultural Clearance on 500 acres of Private ground $15,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Seed (GBRC) Seed for private lands. $100,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Seed (GBRC) Secondary seeding (browse) for private lands $17,500.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Contractual Services Chaining for private lands (500 acres) $50,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Equipment Rental/Use Planting secondary seeding with bitterbrush planter on private lands. Private landowner will pull seeder ($50/ac*125 ac) $0.00 $0.00 $6,250.00 2020
Contractual Services Seed flight for private lands @ $10/ac $5,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Archaeological Clearance BLM - Cultural Clearances ($30/acre) - 10,853 acres $380,000.00 $9,000.00 $0.00 2020
Contractual Services BLM - Chaining (~$75/acre) - 10,853 acres $815,000.00 $82,000.00 $0.00 2020
Seed (GBRC) BLM - General Seed Mix (13,208 acres) - $759,552 BLM - Green Strip Seed Mix (729 acres) - $36,007 BLM - Shrub Seed Mix (10,129 acres) - $204,826 $1,015,000.00 $21,000.00 $0.00 2020
Contractual Services BLM - Aerial Seeding General Seed Mix (Flight 1) - 13,208 acres ($198,120) Green Strip Seed Mix (Flight 2) - 729 acres ($10,935) Shrub Seed Mix (Flight 3) - 10,129 acres ($151,935) Total Acres - 24,066 acres (Note: Some acreage flown twice) $375,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Contractual Services BLM - Plateau Treatment ($30/acre) - 2,154 acres $64,620.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Contractual Services BLM - Sagebrush Seedlings and Planting (50,000 seedlings) - Important Sage Grouse Habitat) $210,000.00 $9,000.00 $0.00 2020
Materials and Supplies BLM - Wildlife Guzzler - Replacement/Upgrade $30,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Equipment Purchase Funding will be utilized to purchase and deploy fifteen solar PTT transmitters on sage grouse in collaboration with USU/SUU extension, UDWR and BLM (See Attached Neck Fire Sage Grouse Telemetry Proposal). $85,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Archaeological Clearance SITLA - Cultural Clearances ($30/ac) 1,233 ac $36,990.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Seed (GBRC) SITLA -seed mixes are same as BLM - General Seed Mix (1,744 acres) $100,292 - Green Strip Seed Mix (61 acres) $3,013 - Shrub Seed Mix (1,744 acres) - $35,266 $138,571.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Contractual Services SITLA - Chaining ($75/acre) - 1,673 acres $125,475.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Contractual Services SITLA - Aerial Seeding General Seed Mix (Flight 1) - 1,744 acres ($26,160) Green Strip Seed Mix (Flight 2) - 61 acres ($915) Shrub Seed Mix (Flight 3) - 1,673 acres ($25,095) Total Acres - 3,478 acres (Note: Some acreage flown twice) $52,170.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Contractual Services SITLA - Plateau Treatment ($30/acre) - 362 acres $10,860.00 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Funding WRI/DWR Other Funding Total In-Kind Grand Total
$2,964,590.97 $512,500.00 $3,477,090.97 $6,250.00 $3,483,340.97
Source Phase Description Amount Other In-Kind Year
DNR Fire Rehab U027 $114,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 2021
Utah Trust Lands Administration (TLA) U037 $156,599.51 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Utah Trust Lands Administration (TLA) U063 $88,400.31 $0.00 $0.00 2020
BLM ESR A111 Mod 2 - $649,334 Mod 3 - $950k $1,315,599.69 $0.00 $0.00 2020
Utah Division of Wildlife Resources (UDWR) Equipment Rental - Bitterbrush Planter $0.00 $0.00 $6,250.00 2020
BLM ESR ES&R (BLM) - Cultural Clearances, Seed Purchase, Chaining, Sagebrush and Bitterbrush Plantings, Sage Grouse monitoring, ESR planning $0.00 $512,500.00 $0.00 2020
BLM ESR A111 Mod 4 - $1,006,257.15 plus Mod 3 carry-over $1,289,991.46 $0.00 $0.00 2021
Species
Species "N" Rank HIG/F Rank
Greater Sage-grouse N3 R1
Threat Impact
Data Gaps - Cheatgrass Impacts NA
Greater Sage-grouse N3 R1
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity Very High
Mule Deer R1
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity High
Mule Deer R1
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native High
Pronghorn R3
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity Medium
Utah Prairie Dog N1
Threat Impact
Habitat Shifting and Alteration High
Utah Prairie Dog N1
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity Low
Habitats
Habitat
Lowland Sagebrush
Threat Impact
Droughts High
Mountain Sagebrush
Threat Impact
Habitat Shifting and Alteration Medium
Mountain Sagebrush
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity Medium
Mountain Sagebrush
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native Medium
Project Comments
Comment 10/08/2019 Type: 1 Commenter: Scott Chamberlain
Martin, Is there away to increase the kochia in mix #2 to 1 lb/ac? Also, is the shrub component of Mix #2 going to be dribbled on to the flats. The four wing will do well there but the Bitter brush may not work as well in the flats.
Comment 10/10/2019 Type: 1 Commenter: Scott Chamberlain
Shawn or Martin, I am still considering using the same seed mix the BLM is. Do you want me to just increase the acres in the seed mix spreadsheet? Or do you want me to add additional spreadsheets? Also, I am still hoping to see an increase on the Kochia for the shrub.
Comment 10/11/2019 Type: 1 Commenter: Martin Esplin
As discussed via phone call, the SITLA acres were added to the spreadsheet for the seed mix.
Comment 09/15/2021 Type: 2 Commenter: Alison Whittaker
Please fill out the Completion Form ASAP. Completion reports were due August 31st. If you have any questions about this don't hesitate to contact me. Thanks.
Comment 09/16/2021 Type: 2 Commenter: Martin Esplin
I filled out the completion form. I updated the financial for the BLM funding side. The map needs some adjusting. Should I finalize the completion form and update the map later when we can get details worked out?
Comment 09/23/2021 Type: 2 Commenter: Martin Esplin
I have submitted the completion report.
Comment 09/28/2021 Type: 2 Commenter: Alison Whittaker
Martin - I am not sure who with DWR you have mostly worked with on this but please get with them or Liz Dodson and have them help you with the mapping portion of the completion report. It sounds like you have multiple aerial treatments that need to be displayed and it is not the same across the area. If you could get this done ASAP I would really appreciate it. I am working on the Legislature report and want to have accurate data. Thanks.
Comment 09/30/2021 Type: 2 Commenter: Martin Esplin
I worked with Liz and resubmitted this.
Comment 09/30/2021 Type: 2 Commenter: Martin Esplin
The lable of 2 way is an error, we tried to change it but only received error notices from the program.
Completion
Start Date:
12/20/2019
End Date:
06/23/2021
FY Implemented:
2021
Final Methods:
The methods to perform the emergency stabilization and rehabilitation on the burned area of the Neck Fire (18,769 acres) were aerial seeded and chained using an Ely chain. The aerial seeding was done in multiple applications. First the general seeding was done on 14,945 acres on BLM and State land. The seeds were forbs and perennial grasses. At same time seed was applied on 793 acres of private land in the burn. The following applications were a shrub seeding on 11,802 acres of BLM and State land and a supplemental (reseeding) on 4,265 acres over part of the previous general seeding. Hammond Helicopter was the seeding contractor and GBRC supplied the seed for all of the seedings. The chaining was done in two stages. First the BLM fire personnel performed the chaining on cerca 6,000 acres. Secondly, a contractor (Deer Valley Sand & Gravel) chained an area marked at 4,265 acres. The chaining is useful for turning applied seeding into the soil and putting down dead burned vegetation, mainly tree skeletons, that were still standing after the fire.
Project Narrative:
The Neck Fire burned this area in September 2019. The initial general seeding was done in December 2019 and January 2020. Chaining started later in the winter of 2020 and continued into the spring of 2020 as cultural surveys where completed. The acres that could be chained were also limited by topography and soil types conducive to where traversing with bulldozers pulling the large anchor chain was possible. The cultural survey contract was entirely completed in 2020, though chaining would need to be resumed after the summer season for fire safety and logistical reasons. The shrub seeding was applied in spring 2021 along with a supplement reseeding of the areas not yet chained. The last portion of project needed to be chained was contracted out and done in June 2021.
Future Management:
Photo inventory before and after treatment has been done and will continue to monitor the state and progress of vegetation reestablishment. Rest from livestock grazing for two growing seasons is planned to occur for plant re-establishment. BLM employees will monitor the site for compliance. The AIM method of monitoring has been implemented in at various sites in the project to quantify plant species frequency and diversity. Nested frequency and utilization monitoring will also continue as it was before the fire in this area.
Map Features
ID Feature Category Action Treatement/Type
11918 Terrestrial Treatment Area Anchor chain Ely (1-way)
11919 Terrestrial Treatment Area Anchor chain Ely (1-way)
11919 Terrestrial Treatment Area Seeding (primary) Broadcast (aerial-fixed wing)
11920 Terrestrial Treatment Area Anchor chain Ely (1-way)
11920 Terrestrial Treatment Area Seeding (primary) Broadcast (aerial-fixed wing)
11920 Terrestrial Treatment Area Seeding (secondary/shrub) Broadcast (aerial-fixed wing)
11921 Terrestrial Treatment Area Seeding (primary) Broadcast (aerial-fixed wing)
Project Map
Project Map