Dolores River Restoration 6.0 - Utah
Project ID: 5968
Status: Completed
Fiscal Year: 2023
Submitted By: 488
Project Manager: Gabriel Bissonette
PM Agency: Bureau of Land Management
PM Office: Moab
Lead: Bureau of Land Management
WRI Region: Southeastern
Description:
This project will help enhance and restore 224 acres along the Dolores River in Grand County through: (1) Woody invasive removal underneath two large cottonwood galleries with vehicle access and additional removal in raft-only accessible areas; (2) Control of herbaceous weeds & tamarisk re-sprouts using a combination of herbicide application and seeding; (3) Native Fish Sampling within newly reconnected side channel at the berm site, and (4) Active revegetation of native woody species.
Location:
Work will occur on prioritized sites along the Dolores River, between the State-line site (river-mile 149) and Robert's Bottom (river-mile 170), in Grand County, Utah. Sites have been prioritized based on DRRP's ecological, social, feasibility criteria, and locations of side channel/confluence habitat. For more specifics on locations of specific restoration treatments, please refer to the accompanying map and/or the project details page.
Project Need
Need For Project:
The establishment of tamarisk, Russian olive, and other non-native invasive plants along the Dolores River during the 20th century negatively impacted riparian and aquatic habitats. Dense stands of tamarisk displaced native plants, degraded fish and wildlife habitat, reduced forage for livestock and wildlife, limited human access to the river, interfered with the natural fluvial processes of the river and increased the risk of severe wildfires within native cottonwood stands. The impacts of tamarisk on aquatic habitats are sometimes not fully quantified, but tamarisk tends to eliminate side channel and backwater habitats that provide critical spawning and nursery habitat for native fish, particularly in regulated rivers, by trapping sediments, reducing in-stream habitat complexity in a manner that negatively impacts rare native fishes, and reducing the input of key nutrients that support aquatic food webs (Graf 1978, Geological Society of American Bulletin 89:1149-1501; Bailey et al. 2001, Wetlands 21:442-447; Keller et al. 2014, Environmental Management 54:465-478). Inventory and monitoring of riparian habitats by Tamarisk Coalition (now RiversEdge West) and the University of Denver revealed a pattern of establishment and spread of very dense stands of tamarisk accompanied by the displacement of diverse native plant communities along major stretches of the Dolores River. Beginning in 2009, the Dolores River Restoration Partnership (DRRP), which includes participants from a variety of public and private organizations (including four BLM field offices in Utah and Colorado), identified and began treating over 1,900 acres of impacted riparian habitat dominated by tamarisk and other invasive plants in an effort to restore native vegetation and improve the quality of riparian and riverine habitats. The DRRP continues to treat tamarisk and other noxious woody and herbaceous vegetation upstream in Colorado and has completed 1,931 acres of initial tamarisk removal, 2,600 acres of tamarisk re-sprouts, 3,767 acres of secondary weed treatments, and 612 acres of active revegetation since 2009 in Colorado and Utah. The proposed project builds upon previous efforts and is needed to complete the initial removal of tamarisk underneath mature cottonwood galleries that occur within larger cottonwood gallery complexes. This project will also provide follow-up maintenance of woody invasive re-sprouts at other sites including the recently inundated side-channel portion of the berm removal site that provides important habitat for juvenile native fish. Finally, this project seeks to enhance understory conditions at several previously treated areas by treating secondary weeds and revegetating certain sites with native tree cuttings and seed. One area where maintenance and enhancement activities will occur is at the berm site at Stateline between river mile 150-151. The flow path of the newly reconnected side channel is now evident, particularly in 2019 with high flows, and previous work to clear the flow path of non-natives was successful. Very little follow-up maintenance is required at this time except for isolated individual Russian olives re-sprouts. Minimal maintenance efforts at this site will prevent re-infestation and proliferation of Russian olive and will continue to allow the side channel to flow freely when hydrologic conditions allow. Initial invasive removal focusing on removing ladder fuels and competition underneath and adjacent to the native cottonwood stand across from the berm site (river right) was completed in 2019 and and 2020 under the Dolores 3.0 and 4.0 projects. Native shrubs are also prolific at this site mixed in with the tamarisk. One more season of work is necessary to complete the removal of both tamarisk and Russian olive at this location. In the Beaver Creek to Rio Mesa reach (river mile 155-160), 2 sites have been prioritized for initial removal efforts and 4 sites from 2018/2019 will be evaluated and treated for re-sprouts. The establishment of tamarisk in this area has altered fluvial processes and increased rates of sedimentation, leading to the loss of the side channel, which historically served as important spawning and juvenile habitats for sensitive and endangered fishes. Impacts to native riparian vegetation and wildlife have been equally significant. Many of these areas have an adequate cover of native species and are expected to recover through passive regeneration. These 6 sites can only be accessed by raft during high water which coincides with the presence of Southwestern Willow Flycatcher. Similar to our 2017 (Dolores 1.0) and 2019 (Dolores 3.0) campaign, a bird biologist will need to assess bird occupancy ahead of the raft crews. Three "contingency" units have been identified in the Rio Mesa to the Colorado River Confluence reach between river mile 163-165. If the upstream raft units can't be treated because of the presence of SWFL then work will be initiated on these sites. A raft trip was not possible in 2020 or 2021 under the Dolores 4.0 and 5.0 projects due to a lack of flows to allow a boat through. If flows in 2023 are not adequate to boat crews in, those resources will be allocated to upstream Roberts Bottom site during the same time frame. That also includes conducting bird surveys to ensure that no nesting birds are impacted by restoration activities. Initial removal of non-native tamarisk will continue upstream of Robert's Bottom on river left clearing out ladder fuels and competition from underneath a large cottonwood gallery and around the diverse native shrub understory. These treatments are important management tools to help restore native riparian vegetation as a means of improving fluvial processes, increasing the quality of riparian vegetation for wildlife and livestock, and reducing fire danger. It is estimated work here will be required for at least two more years.
Objectives:
The overall objective of this project is to restore riparian and aquatic habitats along the Dolores River to a more diverse, functional, self-sustaining, and resilient condition. Progress will be assessed based on DRRP's long-term ecological objectives: reducing live tamarisk to less than 5 percent of the vegetation cover; reducing other invasive, non-native plants to less than 15 percent of the vegetation cover; maintaining total vegetation cover equal to or greater than 30 percent; and documenting passive recruitment of native plants towards species-specific thresholds in the riparian corridor. Social and economic objectives also play a role in this project. Hiring local contractors and youth conservation crews are central to on-the-ground work, in order to put money in small rural economies and provide training and skills to youth interested in environmental stewardship.
Project Location/Timing Justification (Why Here? Why Now?):
A variety of threats that have degraded riparian habitat along the Dolores River in Utah will be addressed with this proposed work. Motorized forms of recreation have damaged native plant communities and spread noxious weeds at the Stateline and Roberts Bottom sites. Dense stands of tamarisk have increased fuel loads and, with their deep root systems, altered the sediment transport balance and simplified riverine habitat along vast stretches of the twenty-two miles of the Dolores River's course in eastern Utah. Many of these stretches are also dominated by a suite of invasive, non-native plants that accompany tamarisk, such as Russian knapweed and kochia. By improving the diversity and health of the plant community in the historic floodplain, habitat improvements supporting aquatic species (e.g. better nutrient inputs and increased habitat diversity for desert fish), riparian species (e.g. enhanced cover and food for migrating southwestern willow flycatchers), and upland species (e.g. forbs in the upper river terraces for big-horn sheep) will occur. Currently, the biggest risk is not building on past investments effectively to restore native plant communities to a healthier, increasingly self-sustaining level. In some of the areas proposed within this project, invasive plant densities are yet reduced to a level of low-intensity maintenance; failure to build on past work in these areas in a timely manner will detract from previous restoration efforts and increase costs down the road for improving habitat and reducing fuel loads. Increased intensity and frequency of wildfires is a large risk, in particular, the potential to burn cottonwood galleries, which are critical to riparian health and provide habitat. Based on reduced spring peak flows from upstream diversions and drought, cottonwoods are less-likely to naturally propagate as abundantly as in the past (Coble and Kolb, 2012.) Increased recreational use also increases the potential for accidental human caused fires. As such, it is critical this project protects naturally occurring cottonwoods from catastrophic, ecosystem changing wildfire.
Relation To Management Plan:
(1) The Moab Field Office's Programmatic Invasive Species Management Plan (PISMP) uses an integrated pest management approach to eradicate, contain, control, and prevent targeted weeds within the MFO. The desired goal is to contain or control the spread of invasive species, and eradicate species that pose the greatest threat to the biological diversity within the MFO, and prevent any new weeds from becoming established by utilizing a wide range of treatment options (i.e. mechanical, manual, herbicide, etc.). The resulting pro-active management of these plants would promote the areas ecosystem health and promote diverse native communities by maintaining and improving native forbs and grass species, increasing the regeneration of native cottonwoods and willows in riparian corridors, and ultimately preventing the loss of wildlife habitat, species diversity, and wildfire risk. (2) Moab BLM Resource Management Plan (RMP) prioritizes management of riparian vegetation and emphasizes the control of noxious weeds, prevention of the spread of invasive species, and restoration of vegetated areas. Reduction of tamarisk and restoration of native riparian vegetation addresses management objectives for improving the quality and health of riparian habitats while improving the quality of resources used in recreation and reducing fuels in a manner that decreases the likelihood and severity of wildfires. Specific management decisions in the RMP that are directly related to the primary objectives of the proposed project include RIP-9, which calls for restoring riparian vegetation "through biological, chemical, mechanical, and manual methods (e.g., tamarisk control, willow plantings)," and RIP-16, which calls for implementation of strategies to "restore degraded riparian communities" and "protect natural flow regimes." (3) The project addresses goals and objectives of the BLM Utah Riparian Policy, which states that "riparian areas are to be improved at every opportunity." (4) The Wildlife Action Plan (WAP) for the State of Utah identifies lowland riparian habitat as being highest priority for conservation and restoration. UDWR has designated segments of the Dolores River corridor as "essential habitat" due to its cottonwood gallery, high avian biodiversity, importance as turkey habitat and deer winter range, importance to breeding and overwintering waterfowl, and use by bald eagles and peregrine falcons. Page 58. Improving Condition (of Aquatic-Forested habitat) A good strategy for management may include the following elements: * Promoting policies that maintain or restore natural water and sediment flow regimes. * Promoting policies that reduce inappropriate grazing by domestic livestock and wildlife. * Promoting policies that reduce inappropriate siting of roads in riparian zones. * Promoting policies that reduce inappropriate residential and commercial development in floodplains. * Continuing the use of appropriate methods for reducing the spread and dominance of invasive weeds, including "early detection -- rapid response" programs.] (5) The Range-wide Conservation Agreement and Strategy for Roundtail Chub Gila robusta, Bluehead Sucker Catostomus discobolus, and Flannelmouth Sucker Catostomus latipinnes (UDWR Publication 06-18) includes an objective of enhancing and maintaining habitat for each of the three species. Tamarisk removal and side channel restoration has been an important component of this effort in other parts of Utah. All three of the "three species" are present in the Dolores River. (6) The proposed project supports the goals of DRRP's 2010 Dolores River Riparian Action Plan and 2015 DRRP Transition Plan for Monitoring and Maintenance, which outline restoration goals, objectives, and methods for restoring and managing 175 miles of the Dolores River from McPhee Reservoir in Colorado to the confluence with the Colorado River in Utah. (7) The Utah Mule Deer Statewide Management Plan calls for an emphasis on improving riparian habitat and use of seed mixes that include sufficient forbs and browse species (Habitat Objective 2). (8) Pursuant to the Utah Noxious Weed Act, Section 7, to every person who owns or controls lands in Grand County, Utah, that noxious weeds standing, being, or growing on such land shall be controlled and the spread of same prevented by effective cutting, tillage, cropping, pasturing, or treating with chemicals or other methods, or combination methods, or combination thereof, approved by the County Weed Supervisor, as often as may be required to prevent the weed from blooming and maturing seeds, or spreading by root, root stalks or other means. Listed species that DRRP will manage include hoary cress, tamarisk, Russian knapweed, and Russian olive. (9) Middle Colorado River Watershed Cooperative Weed Management Area Cooperative Agreement - partnering organizations working along the Dolores River work towards the CWMA's goal "to promote an integrated weed management program throughout the MCRW-CWMA that includes public relations, education and training in the non-native invasive weed arena as well as inventory, monitoring, controlling and preventing the spread of non-native invasive weeds, sharing of resources, and designing other desirable resource protection measures relative to weed management." (10) BLM Healthy Lands Initiative: The DRRP project area has been identified as a focal area of this vegetation-resources enhancement initiative to restore and improve the health and productivity of western public lands. The Healthy Lands strategy increases the effectiveness and efficiency of vegetation enhancement treatments by focusing on treatments on a significant percentage of lands -- both Federal and non-Federal -- within six geographic locations, rather than focusing on the local project level. The strategy increases opportunities to leverage cooperative solutions across ownership's and jurisdictions. (11) U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service Utah Partners for Fish and Wildlife Program Strategic Plan: This project falls within a priority area, priority habitat (riparian), and addresses threats to priority species (SWFL and YBCU).
Fire / Fuels:
Establishment of dense stands of dead/dying tamarisk greatly increases the likelihood of destructive wildfires, especially in the vicinity of campsites and other locations of concentrated human activity. A major benefit from this project will be the reduction of unnaturally high fire risk by clearing tamarisk away from cottonwood galleries and campsites and from thinning tamarisk in a manner that creates fire breaks and allows native vegetation to recolonize. Russian knapweed can increase in biomass and ground cover after a fire because of it's adaptations to disturbance and knapweed growing points are below ground. A wildfire in this area without treatment would further spread noxious knapweed.
Water Quality/Quantity:
Municipalities downstream of the Dolores River, namely Moab, Utah, may benefit from decreased salinity inputs and increased filtration via a healthier riparian habitat. Large-scale tamarisk removal has the potential to improve water quality by reducing the salinity-concentrating effects of tamarisk infestations on Dolores River riparian habitats. Tamarisk removal techniques have been adapted, over several years of experience, to minimize soil disturbance and protect water quality. Further, improving floodplain connectivity helps remove sediment and pathogens, increases allochthonous nutrients that stimulate natural nitrogen and phosphorus cycling (Wolf et al. 2012), Installation and fostering of native-species container plants and pole cuttings will further stabilize river banks and riparian soils. And, since tamarisk and Russian knapweed have high rates of evapotranspiration, the long-term conversion to (mesic) native vegetation on Dolores River floodplains will yield water quantity savings in the river. Removal of tamarisk and Russian olive has been linked to saving water and over time water quality increases (Shafroth et al. 2009).
Compliance:
A Determination of NEPA Adequacy (DNA) is completed and is tiered to the BLM Moab Field Office Programmatic Invasive Species Management Plan (2016) and will conform to its stipulations and restrictions. Consultation with BLM archaeologists has already occurred. The BLM Moab Pesticide Use Plan has also been approved for the Dolores. ESA Section 7 Consultation occurred with the USFWS and wildlife surveys will be conducted prior to any spring work or work will commence after nesting season. An EA will be prepared for the prescribed grazing component but NEPA has been completed for all other actions associated with this proposal.
Methods:
Sites have been selected based on DRRP's prioritization criteria that consider ecological, social, and feasibility factors. The methods outlined below are organized from upstream to downstream. STATELINE (Vehicle Accessible): Cottonwood Gallery Across from the Berm Site (River Right): 1.2 acres of initial tamarisk removal from underneath and adjacent to a large cottonwood gallery was completed in the fall of 2019 under the Dolores 3.0 project and another 3.1 acres was completed in 2020 under Dolores 4.0. Re-sprouts and additional removal of tamarisk was completed on 82.5 acres in 2020/21 under the Dolores 4.0 project. Additional work is required to finish removing roughly 2 acres of dense tamarisk and dispersed Russian olive in order to reduce competition and eliminate ladder fuels. Removal is conducted by Conservation Corps crews using a cut-stump method. After cutting tamarisk trees with chainsaws, crews apply herbicide (Triclopyr, Glyphosate) to the freshly cut tamarisk stumps during the fall (September - early November) of 2021. Areas underneath cottonwood galleries are treated with 100% removal. To protect previous investments, any resprouts from previous work will be treated with a basal bark/foliar treatment. For more detailed information please reference the statement of work and map associated with this site in the Documents/Images tab. Cottonwood cuttings will be taken from above Robert's Bottom in 2021 and planted at this site in open areas in order to help facilitate re-growth. There are a few areas that do not have any mature native trees. therefore this will assist in the restoration of this site. Additionally, native seed will be broadcast here over 4 acres. As noted in the 4.0 and 5.0 report, Southwest Willow Flycatcher (or another willow flycatcher) was observed at this site in early 2021, which makes habitat restoration here a priority for project partners. BERM SITE (River Left): The upstream end of the gravel berm was removed in February of 2019 and water flowed through the historic channel. The flowpath was cleared of tamarisk and Russian olive in previous project phases to allow for improved hydrological function when reconnected. This site now has a functioning side channel with cottonwood regeneration, sedges and rush colonization, and utilization by red-spotted and woodhouse toads, fish, beaver, bear, and mountain lion. In March, 2020 15 gross acres of Russian olive re-sprouts were treated by the DRRP strike team. Future work at and around this site consists of the removal/re-treatment of Russian olive trees as needed, using a cut-stump/lop and scatter method. Removal of these few trees is important to eliminate Russian olive at this site and protect the previous investments from future invasion. Russian olive will also be spot treated in and around this site. For more detailed information please reference the statement of work and map associated with this site in the Documents/Images tab. BEAVER CREEK to RIO MESA REACH & CONTINGENCY UNITS (Raft-Accessible): In the Beaver Creek to Rio Mesa reach (river mile 155-160), 2 sites have been prioritized for initial removal efforts (8.4 acres) and four sites from 2018/2019 will be evaluated and treated for resprouts (9.3 acres). Removal is conducted by Conservation Corps crews using a cut-stump method. After cutting tamarisk trees with chainsaws, crews apply herbicide (Triclopyr or Glyphosate) to the freshly cut tamarisk stumps during the fall (September - early November) of 2021. To protect previous investments, any resprouts from previous work will be treated with a basal bark/foliar treatment. These sites can only be accessed by raft during high water which coincides with the presence of Southwestern Willow Flycatcher. Similar to our 2017 (Dolores 1.0) and 2019 (Dolores 3.0) campaign, a bird biologist will need to assess bird occupancy ahead of the raft crews. Three "contingency" units have been identified in the Rio Mesa to the Colorado River Confluence reach between river mile 163-165. If the upstream raft units can't be treated because of the presence of SWFL then work will be initiated on these sites. A raft trip was not possible under the Dolores 3.0 project in the spring of 2020 due to very low flows. A mosaic treatment approach consisting of the removal of 30-50% of the tamarisk biomass is applied in monotypic tamarisk stands. The mosaic treatment of tamarisk will be implemented as a way of reducing tamarisk density while maintaining the degree of soil stability and partially shaded micro-climates necessary to provide conditions beneficial to riparian wildlife and native plants. This strategy, which incorporates the presence of the tamarisk-leaf beetle (a biological control agent), is expected to reduce tamarisk densities in a manner that allows native trees, shrubs, perennial grasses, and herbaceous vegetation to become reestablished. Results from a 2010-2014 DRRP pilot study conducted upriver in the Uncompahgre BLM Field office support using this site-specific integrated-pest management strategy. ROBERT'S BOTTOM & UPSTREAM COTTONWOOD GALLERY (River Right): In an effort to integrate more tools into the Integrated Pest Management (IPM) toolbox for addressing herbaceous weeds, this proposal intends to utilize prescribed grazing with goats to address Kochia and knapweed infestations at Robert's Bottom and at the cottonwood gallery just upstream (100 acres). Using goats as a biological control for weed infestations has many potential environmental and economic benefits including being safer than herbicide, benefitting local goat farmers, and cutting-back native shrubs. Goats are also much easier to control than other biological agents. Goats will be applied when knapweed infestations are "in bloom" to reduce seedhead production. Native seed will be applied prior to the treatment to allow hoof activity to work the seeds into the soil. 2.2 acres of woody invasive removal was completed at the cottonwood gallery upstream of Robert's Bottom in 2019, 1.1 acres in 2020 and 2.15 in 2021. Additional work is required to finish removing the 10.2 acres of tamarisk and Russian olive in order to reduce competition and eliminate ladder fuels. Removal is conducted by Conservation Corps crews using a cut-stump method. After cutting tamarisk trees with chainsaws, crews apply herbicide (Triclopyr or Glyphosate) to the freshly cut tamarisk stumps during the fall (September - early November) of 2020. Areas underneath cottonwood galleries are treated with 100% removal. To protect previous investments, any re-sprouts from previous work will be treated with a basal bark/foliar treatment. For more detailed information please reference the statement of work and map associated with this site in the Documents/Images tab. LAKE BOTTOM (River Right) Across from Robert's Bottom, Lake Bottom is 9.9 acres of private land. Secondary weeds have been treated in 2018, and in 2019 by the landowner. An additional 1 acre of tamarisk re-sprouts was treated in 2020 under 4.0. The main project goal is to remove any initial stands of tamarisk and re-treat re-growth areas that have been previously treated as well as continue to treat secondary weeds. If any Russian olive is present that will also be eradicated. Prioritization is given to areas underneath and surrounding native vegetation, specifically Freemont cottonwood. When cleaning beetle-infested tamarisk, a mosaic method is used in order to leave shade to assist passive recruitment of native species. Primarily, treatments will be a mixture of basal bark for small tamarisk-re-growth, and cut-sump or frill cut method for larger tamarisk or Russian olive trees. These treatments will protect native plant restoration through decreased competition, protect native plants from fire risk, promote passive restoration through decreased competition, and slow the growth of tamarisk and Russian olive. OTHER INFORMATION: Seeding will be conducted in targeted sites (e.g., where there is bare soil, in tamarisk slash piles, and in kochia infestations) to impede re-encroachment of invasive plants as well as to improve forage for livestock and habitat for wildlife. Species have been selected based on successes of previous re-vegetation efforts along the Dolores River and on recommendations from UT-DWR during last year's WRI comment period. Active re-vegetation (e.g., species, micro-site selection, & planting methods) will be conducted at certain sites to address specific restoration objectives and based on lessons learned and shared during past DRRP Implementation Committee meetings.
Monitoring:
Coordinated by the DRRP Coordinators and BLM employees, long-term monitoring of vegetation/riparian condition (rapid monitoring protocol), and breeding birds will be conducted at treatment sites to assess the effectiveness of the treatments and to guide future management efforts. BLM staff will be onsite at the beginning, during critical stages of the project, and near completion to ensure desirable results. Partners will be invited to do onsite visits as well to ensure increased input and share concerns. Data gathered will be available to upload into the WRI database for future analysis and review. Rapid Monitoring was developed specifically for the needs of the DRRP and includes the collection of non-native/native cover-class data, tamarisk cover, noxious weed invasions, presence of the tamarisk leaf beetle, wildlife presence, passive recruitment of native vegetation, and photos to document progress. Annually, this data is used to inform future management actions, track the effectiveness of various treatment methods, and engage various partners. Rapid monitoring of treatment sites accessible by vehicle was conducted in the Summer of 2020 and the Summer of 2021. No DRRP monitoring is planned until 2023. Please find the reports and photo point presentations in the images and documents section. The Southwest Conservation Corps (SCC) recruits and selects two-person roving teams to conduct vegetation and weed monitoring utilizing Collector for ArcGIS on tablets. This team also compiles monitoring and photo-point reports at the end of the monitoring season for BLM land managers. Training and oversight are co-managed between SCC and RiversEdge West. Partners from UT Division of Wildlife Resources and Colorado Parks and Wildlife will monitor the use of side-channel habitat by native fish species to evaluate success towards creating backwater habitat for juvenile fish, while partners from Bird Conservancy of the Rockies will continue long-term monitoring of how restoration work impacts avian communities via the Integrated Monitoring in Bird Conservation Regions program. The Grand County Weed Department completed the first season of quantitative pre-treatment (prescribed grazing) monitoring using a subset of the BLM Terrestrial AIM protocol at Robert's Bottom. Methods include line-point intercept cover and cottonwood belt density. The BLM Lentic AIM crew collected quantitative data on BLM in 2020 at the site upstream from Robert's Bottom and at Lake Bottom on BLM. Lentic protocols include soil pit verification, line point intercept cover, vegetation height, and species richness. Additional, sites may be located within other project areas, budget permitting. Partners from the Grand County Weed Department will implement the phenological monitoring in the spring of 2020 (in-kind funds) at Robert's Bottom to determine the best window to implement the prescribed grazing in 2021. GCWD will also monitor pre- and post-treatment conditions following the prescribed grazing treatment.
Partners:
In 2015, thirty local, state, federal, and private organizations signed a five-year memorandum of understanding (MOU) committing to protecting and building on shared investments in the collaborative restoration of the Dolores River through 2020. The Dolores River Restoration Partnership (DRRP) promotes riparian restoration along almost 200 miles of the river corridor, monitors progress, and coordinates with numerous other conservation activities in the watershed. Nine of these partners play active roles in the project: RiversEdge West (formerly Tamarisk Coalition): as chair of the DRRP Implementation Subcommittee and DRRP Science and Monitoring Subcommittee, this non-profit organization works with partners to plan, execute, and monitor restoration work across public and private boundaries throughout the partnership's project area. Grand County Weed Department: this local agency conducts re-treatments of tamarisk and herbaceous weeds, monitoring work, as well as provides technical assistance (e.g., sharing findings from biological control monitoring) to inform restoration work. University of Utah Rio Mesa Center: the University works with student groups to foster education, research, stewardship, and restoration along the Center's portion of the Dolores River in the Utah Bottoms. Utah Division of Wildlife Resources: this state agency provides technical assistance to DRRP (e.g., surveying for side-channel revitalization project) and monitors the avian community along the Utah-portion of the Dolores River to increase understanding of how restoration affects bird species. US Fish and Wildlife Service Partners for Fish and Wildlife Program: this federal program coordinates with a significant private landowner at Lake Bottom, supports the Rio Mesa Center, and provides technical support that informs DRRP restoration strategies. Canyon Country Youth Corps: a program of the Four Corners School of Outdoor Education, CCYC hires and trains young adults to implement restoration work, including installation and repair of fencing, tamarisk control, and active revegetation of native plant species along the Dolores River in Utah. Conservation Legacy's Southwest Conservation Corps (SCC): working with CCYC and Western Colorado Conservation Corps, SCC hires and trains young adults to implement restoration work, including tamarisk control, active revegetation of native plant species, and monitoring of restoration projects. SCC's Watershed Programs Coordinator also helps with planning and field support for crews. Western Colorado Conservation Corps: working with the other two Corps programs, this non-profit organization hires and trains young adults to implement restoration work, including tamarisk control and treatment of Russian knapweed and hoary cress. National Wild Turkey Federation: has provided funding and in-kind support to foster stewardship and active re-vegetation along the Dolores River. While the Moab BLM is submitting this WRI proposal, it is worth noting that three other BLM field offices (Tres Rios, Uncompahgre, and Grand Junction in CO), two-state BLM offices (UT & CO), two district BLM offices (UT-Canyon Country & CO-Northwest), and the national office are all engaged partners, providing in-kind and/or financial support towards achieving the DRRP's shared ecological, social, economic, and management goals.
Future Management:
The project is part of a multi-year effort that will involve follow-up monitoring, active re-vegetation, and treatments to control remaining infestations of priority non-native, invasive plant species such as tamarisk, Russian olive, Russian knapweed, kochia, and hoary cress. Some temporary fence has already been constructed along the Dolores River where knapweed is common to assist with the treatment areas to lessen livestock presence while native plants establish. The long-term goal is to restore riparian and floodplain habitats along the lower Dolores River in a manner that creates diverse riparian communities comprised primarily of native plant species as a means of improving the condition and resiliency of riparian and aquatic habitats. This will require an adaptive management approach. Long-term, adaptive management strategies have been outlined in the DRRP Transition Plan for Long-Term Monitoring & Maintenance. A 2015, MOU signed by thirty partners affirms their commitment towards implementing the Transition Plan to build on seven years of restoration work to achieve a shared set of ecological, social, economic, and management goals through 2020. A subsequent MOU is currently being signed by partners; reaffirming the importance of the DRRP for another five years. The DRRP has continuously served as a nucleus for information, on-the-ground work, and by garnering additional funding. The private landowner in Lake Bottom has been working with the USFWS Partners Program for the last few years and currently has an agreement to manage and maintain the project area in a manner that benefits wildlife habitats. This agreement is for 10 years and under that agreement, USFWS will monitor the project annually and work with the landowner to ensure project success. Currently, the Lake Bottom property is not used for livestock grazing. Under the USFWS agreement, the landowner has agreed that if in the future livestock will be used on the property that they will work with USFWS and other partners on a grazing plan.
Sustainable Uses of Natural Resources:
The removal of tamarisk, Russian knapweed, and other invasive vegetation species will allow multiple uses of the Dolores River and the surrounding landscape to be more sustainable for generations to come. Collectively, the actions in this project coupled with projects upstream in Colorado will make the Dolores a more resilient system in the long-term. This project will greatly benefit the riparian ecosystem, desert fish, birds, improve recreation, water quality, agriculture, and many other uses. The removal of tamarisk and Russian knapweed is expected to greatly benefit domestic livestock in three ways: First, it will facilitate the re-establishment of perennial grasses, native forbs, and shrubs that have much higher forage value than tamarisk. Past knapweed treatments upstream from the project area have led to the rapid re-establishment of perennial grasses, even in the absence of seeding. However, targeted broadcast seeding will be used to accelerate the recolonization of native grasses in selected areas where native grasses are sparse in habitat adjacent to the treatment site. Second, control of tamarisk can make managing livestock easier. Previously dense stands of tamarisk that have either been removed or thinned (depending on site-conditions) increases access for ranchers to monitor and manage cattle on public allotments. Therefore, grazing and animal distribution will increase since more riverbank is accessible for watering livestock and wildlife. Finally, since greater access to the river is available following tamarisk removal, it leads to less stress on previous riparian areas hammered with livestock watering. Third, Russian knapweed is known to be toxic to horses, potentially causing facial paralysis, malnutrition, dehydration, and necrosis (USDA Agr Info Bulletin Number 415). Controlling this noxious weed will reduce the potential for these and other livestock health issues. The private landowner in Lake Bottom has been resting the property but has had discussions with partners that if goals are met they would potentially like to discuss a holistic grazing strategy.
Budget WRI/DWR Other Budget Total In-Kind Grand Total
$166,199.00 $19,800.00 $185,999.00 $14,600.00 $200,599.00
Item Description WRI Other In-Kind Year
Contractual Services Conservation legacy to help coordinate conservation corps, Strike Teams teams, and other Utah-based DRRP tasks. Other funding from Walton Family Foundation $4,500.00 $2,500.00 $0.00 2023
Contractual Services Active revegetation and seeding at above Roberts Bottom and across from Berm site. In-kind funding comes from RiversEdge West. $6,500.00 $0.00 $500.00 2023
Contractual Services Knapweed spraying by Grand County Weed Dept. at site upstream from Robert's Bottom on river left. Treatment to occur in completed cut-stump removal areas. $2,200.00 $0.00 $800.00 2023
Contractual Services May/June 2023 (Raft) - Funds for GCWD to spray herbaceous weeds with youth corps. (1) One 8-day trip with 2 GCWD crew members/1 raft treating units from Beaver Creek to Granite Creek and/or SWFL contingency units from Rio Mesa to Robert's Bottom. $8,800.00 $0.00 $4,000.00 2023
Contractual Services Fall 2023 (Vehicle) - Woody Invasive removal/seeding by Conservation Corps (8-10 person crew). (1) Five 4-day hitches at berm/cottonwood gallery across river. (2) Three 4-day hitches upstream of R. Bottom. (3) Two 4-day hitches at Lake Bottom. $90,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 2023
Contractual Services May/June 2023 (Raft) - Woody Invasive Removal by Conservation Corps. (1) One 8-day trip with 12-15 crew members treating units from Beaver Creek to Granite Creek and/or SWFL contingency units from Rio Mesa to Robert's Bottom. $30,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 2023
Contractual Services 2023 Southwest Willow Flycatcher (SWFL) Protocol Surveys in May 2023 $5,999.00 $0.00 $0.00 2023
Contractual Services Three weeks DRRP Strike Team to Treat berm site and other tamarisk re-sprouts and knapweed. Other funds come from Forever Our Rivers Foundation via RiversEdge West. In-kind time DRRP coordinators working to identify sites and provide supplies. $9,000.00 $1,500.00 $500.00 2023
Materials and Supplies Herbicide Supplies $1,500.00 $0.00 $0.00 2023
Personal Services (permanent employee) BLM - Project co-management and coordination by BLM Aquatic Habitats Staff: project implementation, monitoring, staff capacity and travel expenses. Pre-work meetings, herbicide, and logistical support of Conservation Corps. $0.00 $0.00 $8,000.00 2023
Contractual Services Project management and coordination by RiversEdge West (REW). Coordinate conservation corps, strike teams, monitoring efforts, and GIS. Cash match through RiversEdge West ROR grant and in-kind from REW Associate Director. (180 hours @ $42.74/hr) $7,700.00 $1,800.00 $800.00 2023
Contractual Services BLM Riparian and Wetland AIM Plots x 4. Lake Bottom, Above Robert's, and Berm 1 and 2. $0.00 $14,000.00 $0.00 2023
Funding WRI/DWR Other Funding Total In-Kind Grand Total
$166,199.00 $19,800.00 $185,999.00 $9,800.00 $195,799.00
Source Phase Description Amount Other In-Kind Year
RiversEdge West REW capacity administering contracts, processing invoices, and managing contractors. $0.00 $1,800.00 $1,800.00 2023
Forever Our Rivers From Forever Our Rivers administered by RiversEdge West for maintenance work and DRRP Strike Team. $0.00 $1,500.00 $0.00 2023
BLM (Aquatics) BLM - Project co-management and coordination by BLM Aquatic Habitats Staff: project implementation, monitoring, staff capacity and travel expenses. Pre-work meetings, herbicide, and logistical support of Conservation Corps. $0.00 $0.00 $8,000.00 2024
Walton Family Foundation For Conservation Legacy's work coordinating maintenance and monitoring in Utah as part of the DRRP. $0.00 $2,500.00 $0.00 2023
DNR Watershed U004 $156,199.00 $0.00 $0.00 2023
BLM Fuels (Canyon Country) A089 -RF $10,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 2023
BLM (Aquatics) BLM Riparian and Wetland AIM Plots x 4 $0.00 $14,000.00 $0.00 2023
Species
Species "N" Rank HIG/F Rank
Bluehead Sucker N4
Threat Impact
Channel Downcutting (indirect, unintentional) Low
Bluehead Sucker N4
Threat Impact
Channelization / Bank Alteration (direct, intentional) High
Bluehead Sucker N4
Threat Impact
Dam / Reservoir Operation High
Bluehead Sucker N4
Threat Impact
Droughts Very High
Bluehead Sucker N4
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity High
Bluehead Sucker N4
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native Medium
Bluehead Sucker N4
Threat Impact
Sediment Transport Imbalance Medium
Bonytail N1
Threat Impact
Channel Downcutting (indirect, unintentional) Low
Bonytail N1
Threat Impact
Channelization / Bank Alteration (direct, intentional) Medium
Bonytail N1
Threat Impact
Dam / Reservoir Operation High
Bonytail N1
Threat Impact
Droughts Very High
Bonytail N1
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity High
Bonytail N1
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native Medium
Bonytail N1
Threat Impact
Sediment Transport Imbalance Medium
Chukar R3
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity Medium
Chukar R3
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native High
Colorado Pikeminnow N1
Threat Impact
Channel Downcutting (indirect, unintentional) Low
Colorado Pikeminnow N1
Threat Impact
Channelization / Bank Alteration (direct, intentional) Medium
Colorado Pikeminnow N1
Threat Impact
Dam / Reservoir Operation High
Colorado Pikeminnow N1
Threat Impact
Droughts Very High
Colorado Pikeminnow N1
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity High
Colorado Pikeminnow N1
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native Medium
Colorado Pikeminnow N1
Threat Impact
Sediment Transport Imbalance Medium
Flannelmouth Sucker N3
Threat Impact
Channel Downcutting (indirect, unintentional) Low
Flannelmouth Sucker N3
Threat Impact
Channelization / Bank Alteration (direct, intentional) High
Flannelmouth Sucker N3
Threat Impact
Dam / Reservoir Operation High
Flannelmouth Sucker N3
Threat Impact
Droughts Very High
Flannelmouth Sucker N3
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity High
Flannelmouth Sucker N3
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native Medium
Flannelmouth Sucker N3
Threat Impact
Sediment Transport Imbalance Medium
Wild Turkey R1
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity Medium
Mule Deer R1
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity High
Mule Deer R1
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native High
Mule Deer R1
Threat Impact
OHV Motorized Recreation Medium
Northern Leopard Frog N5
Threat Impact
Channel Downcutting (indirect, unintentional) Medium
Northern Leopard Frog N5
Threat Impact
Data Gaps - Vulnerability to Chytrid NA
Northern Leopard Frog N5
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity Low
Northern Leopard Frog N5
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native Medium
Northern Leopard Frog N5
Threat Impact
Invasive Wildlife Species - Non-native High
Northern Leopard Frog N5
Threat Impact
Sediment Transport Imbalance Low
Razorback Sucker N1
Threat Impact
Channel Downcutting (indirect, unintentional) Low
Razorback Sucker N1
Threat Impact
Channelization / Bank Alteration (direct, intentional) Medium
Razorback Sucker N1
Threat Impact
Dam / Reservoir Operation High
Razorback Sucker N1
Threat Impact
Droughts Very High
Razorback Sucker N1
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity High
Razorback Sucker N1
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native Medium
Razorback Sucker N1
Threat Impact
Invasive Wildlife Species - Non-native Very High
Razorback Sucker N1
Threat Impact
Sediment Transport Imbalance Medium
Roundtail Chub N3
Threat Impact
Channel Downcutting (indirect, unintentional) Low
Roundtail Chub N3
Threat Impact
Channelization / Bank Alteration (direct, intentional) High
Roundtail Chub N3
Threat Impact
Dam / Reservoir Operation High
Roundtail Chub N3
Threat Impact
Droughts Very High
Roundtail Chub N3
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity High
Roundtail Chub N3
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native Medium
Roundtail Chub N3
Threat Impact
Sediment Transport Imbalance Medium
Southwestern Willow Flycatcher N1
Threat Impact
Data Gaps - Inadequate Understanding of Distribution or Range NA
Southwestern Willow Flycatcher N1
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity Medium
Southwestern Willow Flycatcher N1
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native High
Southwestern Willow Flycatcher N1
Threat Impact
OHV Motorized Recreation High
Western Yellow-billed Cuckoo N3
Threat Impact
Channel Downcutting (indirect, unintentional) High
Western Yellow-billed Cuckoo N3
Threat Impact
Data Gaps - Inadequate Understanding of Distribution or Range NA
Western Yellow-billed Cuckoo N3
Threat Impact
Inappropriate Fire Frequency and Intensity Medium
Western Yellow-billed Cuckoo N3
Threat Impact
OHV Motorized Recreation Medium
Western Yellow-billed Cuckoo N3
Threat Impact
Problematic Plant Species – Native Wetland High
Habitats
Habitat
Aquatic-Forested
Threat Impact
Channel Downcutting (indirect, unintentional) High
Aquatic-Forested
Threat Impact
Channelization / Bank Alteration (direct, intentional) High
Aquatic-Forested
Threat Impact
Dam / Reservoir Operation Medium
Aquatic-Forested
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native Medium
Aquatic-Forested
Threat Impact
Sediment Transport Imbalance Medium
Aquatic-Forested
Threat Impact
Fire and Fire Suppression Low
Aquatic-Scrub/Shrub
Threat Impact
Channel Downcutting (indirect, unintentional) High
Aquatic-Scrub/Shrub
Threat Impact
Channelization / Bank Alteration (direct, intentional) High
Aquatic-Scrub/Shrub
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native Medium
Aquatic-Scrub/Shrub
Threat Impact
OHV Motorized Recreation Low
Aquatic-Scrub/Shrub
Threat Impact
Sediment Transport Imbalance Medium
Aquatic-Scrub/Shrub
Threat Impact
Fire and Fire Suppression Medium
Riverine
Threat Impact
Channel Downcutting (indirect, unintentional) High
Riverine
Threat Impact
Channelization / Bank Alteration (direct, intentional) High
Riverine
Threat Impact
Dam / Reservoir Operation Medium
Riverine
Threat Impact
Droughts High
Riverine
Threat Impact
Invasive Plant Species – Non-native Medium
Riverine
Threat Impact
OHV Motorized Recreation Low
Riverine
Threat Impact
Sediment Transport Imbalance Medium
Project Comments
Comment 01/24/2022 Type: 1 Commenter: Makeda Hanson
Under yellow-billed cuckoo, SWFL, and northern leopard frog, you identified that a threat that will be addressed by this project is data gaps. Your monitoring section mentions surveying for breeding birds; will there be specific surveys for those species?
Comment 01/25/2022 Type: 1 Commenter: Gabriel Bissonette
Hi Makeda - Yes, there is a line item for bird surveys to get clearance for high water raft-based work that occurs during breeding and nesting for SWFL and Cuckoo. We have several years of data that when water levels have been adequate. Leopard frog and bullfrog observations are noted at restoration sites as well as eDNA samples that are taken outside of WRI. Do you think that will suffice?
Comment 08/24/2023 Type: 2 Commenter: Daniel Eddington
This is just a reminder that completion reports are due August 31st. I have entered the expenses in the Through WRI/DWR column on the finance page. Please do not make any changes to numbers in the Through WRI/DWR column. Any "Through Other" or "In-kind" expenses will need to be entered by the PM or contributors. Update your map features and fill out the completion form. Be sure to click on the finalize button on the completion report when you have your completion report ready to be reviewed by WRI Admin. Don't forget to upload any pictures of the project you have of before, during and after completion. If you have any questions about this don't hesitate to contact me. Thanks.
Comment 09/01/2023 Type: 2 Commenter: Alison Whittaker
Gabe - It looks like your map features have not been updated. Your report only mentions about 6 or 7 acres but your map show 10 times that. Will you update the map and then finalize your report again so I know it is ready to be reviewed again? Thanks.
Comment 09/05/2023 Type: 2 Commenter: Gabriel Bissonette
Hi Alison - the map features are correct but let me add more narrative regarding the work done by the stateline. I'll resubmit shortly. Thank you.
Comment 09/05/2023 Type: 2 Commenter: Gabriel Bissonette
I've added additional narrative to clarify that portion of the project. Please let me know you additional clarification or details would be helpful. Thanks!
Completion
Start Date:
07/01/2022
End Date:
06/30/2023
FY Implemented:
2023
Final Methods:
ROBERT'S BOTTOM AREA "Above Robert's Bottom" (River Left): For site-specific treatment methods please reference the 2022 Fall Dolores 6.0 - CCYC Project Report and 2023 Spring Dolores 6.0 - CCYC Project Report. STATELINE AREA -- The Western Colorado Conservation Corps (WCCC) Strike Team treated 24.2 acres of Russian knapweed using Milestone applied with backpack sprayers in March 2023. Knapweed treatments were located immediately upstream of the cottonwood galleries associated with both the "Berm Site" and the "Across from Berm" site. Knapweed abatement also occurred within the "Across from Berm Site" in support of past and future understory restoration efforts. During this treatment campaign, the WCCC also treated 33.2 acres of tamarisk saplings and resprouts using a Garlon 4 in sites where tamarisk removal treatments were implemented 12-15 years ago by the BLM Fuels program, effectively maintaining these previous treatments. Terra Sophia, a local restoration group, planted 100 willow poles along the bank where tamarisk has previously been removed at the "Across the Berm" site. Approximately 0.65 acres were thus revegetated in the fall of 2022. MONITORING: See Attached AIM Reports, DRRP Monitoring Reports.
Project Narrative:
This project's scope was smaller than planned because extraordinary high water conditions resulted in the inundation of the project area "Above Robert's Bottom" and river flows that were too high for the youth corps to safely raft herbicide and equipment to the raft-based sites. The youth corps completed 4.1 acres of tamarisk removal in Oct. 2023. During the high water of spring 2023 the CCYC were diverted to land based treatments accomplishing another 1.5 acres. The Western Colorado Conservation Corp Strike Team, managed by REW, treated 33.2 acres of tamarisk saplings and resprouts and 24.2 acres of Russian knapweed in March 2023. Western Biology, LLC provided SWFL/YBCU clearance surveys to clear the sites for spring treatments. Terra Sophia implemented willow pole planting on 0.65 acres of river bank. The Grand County Weed Department's work was cancelled due to site inundation and the cancelling of the raft-based work but new treatments have been rescheduled for the fall of 2023 and the spring of 2024. RiversEdge West (REW) staff managed project work including the coordination of strike teams performing tamarisk resprouts and secondary weed treatments, conservation corps raft based and terrestrial tamarisk removal, revegetation efforts by contractors, monitoring, and GIS. REW coordinated with and managed contractor Terra Sophia in the fall of 2022 who planted 100 willow whips in cobble and sand beaches and revegetated approximately .65 acres.
Future Management:
The next iteration of Dolores work will focus on removal of the remaining tamarisk within these cottonwood gallery complexes. BLM Aquatics BIL funding has been obligated for additional tamarisk removal. Knapweed treatments with the Grand County Weed Department have been rescheduled for fall 2023 and spring of 2024. An important component of our active restoration work is achieved through hand broadcast of seed, planting of container plants, or burying willow poles. Concerted efforts to load the seed bank with native grasses and flowering forbs are underway and will continue. Sites along the Dolores River may require periodic maintenance. BLM Riparian and Wetland AIM sites and DRRP Rapid monitoring sites will be resampled upon completion of the project.
Map Features
ID Feature Category Action Treatement/Type
12976 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Vegetation Improvements Pole planting/cuttings
12982 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Herbicide application Spot treatment
12983 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Herbicide application Spot treatment
12984 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Herbicide application Ground
13004 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Herbicide application Spot treatment
13005 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Herbicide application Spot treatment
13006 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Herbicide application Spot treatment
13006 Aquatic/Riparian Treatment Area Vegetation Improvements Manual removal / hand crew
Project Map
Project Map